Mets’ Steve Cohen and David Stearns proving to be one of MLB’s best front-office duos

Mets' Steve Cohen and David Stearns proving to be one of MLB's best front-office duos - Newsday

PORT ST. LUCIE, Fla. — The most formidable front-office duo this side of the Mississippi beat super-agent Scott Boras during the negotiations that finally delivered Pete Alonso back to his adoring Flushing fan base.

Eventually, it will be the Dodgers’ turn in the crosshairs.


Because when you combine Steve Cohen’s near-limitless resources and David Stearns’ cool baseball intellect — not to mention their own legit Mets’ fan DNA — that’s a pretty fearsome combo for the industry to deal with, whether it’s the winter talent marketplace or between the lines come summer.

In Alonso’s case, he got the full good-cop, bad-cop routine, and it’s no secret which was which. Sure Cohen showed some teeth during Amazin’ Day at Citi Field, back when he blasted Pete’s camp for “exhausting” negotiations and an untenable sales pitch, but we now know the owner was more sending a message than slamming the door.

Two seats over, there was Stearns, the president of baseball ops, watching Cohen turn boos to cheers just by shooting straight with the audience. While it’s Stearns’ job to build the best roster possible, using every analytical tool at his disposal, Cohen seems more comfortable in the front-facing role, whether it’s connecting with longtime Mets’ loyalists in a parking lot or the players themselves.

“Steve wants to be transparent,” Stearns said Wednesday. “Not every owner does. And so there clearly are rules that govern what we can say. I think what Steve did was be as transparent as he possibly could without breaking any rules. And I applaud him for doing it and appreciate him for doing that.”

Stearns was referring to a clause in the CBA that prohibits teams from going public with details about the negotiating process. But it’s not like Boras would file a grievance against the richest individual owner in the sport — especially Cohen, who’s already given well over a billion dollars to his clients during his four-year ownership of the Mets. That’s not smart business.

Instead, Cohen’s tough talk got everyone back to the table, and less than two weeks later, the Mets got Alonso — at their price — after a face-to-face sitdown in Tampa. Once again, this was Cohen driving the bus, but the contract had Stearns’ fingerprints all over it: a two-year, $54 million deal with an opt-out after the first season. Alonso receives a big chunk up front, a $30 million sum (including a $10 million signing bonus) that makes him the highest-paid player at his position while the Mets don’t get tied up in a long-term commitment (Stearns’ signature move).

That’s teamwork. Clearly, the Mets have a significantly better lineup with Alonso, and Stearns — despite his willingness to move on — stated the obvious Wednesday during his first public comments on the matter. But it was also telling when Stearns was asked about Alonso showing slippage the previous two seasons, first when he batted a meager .217 in 2023 then followed up with career-lows in home runs (34) and OPS (.788) a year ago. Alonso’s downward trend, heading into his age 30 season, begged the question: why invest in a potentially fading stock?

“He’s a really motivated player right now,” Stearns said. “He’s a very motivated player to have an elite Pete Alonso season. I expect we’re going to see that. He is confident in his ability. I’m excited to watch it.”

That’s the beauty of a one-year deal, a strategy that Stearns has executed to near-perfection since coming to the Mets. It may seem counter-intuitive to sign people on the cheap when Cohen, sitting on a $25 billion fortune, has no problem soaring over the luxury tax threshold named in his honor.

But Stearns, given his esteemed baseball ops resume, understands there’s no better carrot than a player’s next contract. It didn’t work for Alonso last season — maybe the pressure of the walk year got to him before his October redemption tour — but Stearns and Cohen evidently figured it was worth a $30 million bet that he’d cash in on a second chance, hitting in a Juan Soto-stacked lineup.

“I think what he expressed to us is he wants to win a World Series as a Met,” Stearns said. “And he knows a big part of our ability to do that is him producing. I think Pete’s had good years the last couple of years, but not as good, not as elite, not at the standard that he set at the front end of his career, and I think he is very motivated to demonstrate that he is capable of putting up those types of numbers.”

If that does happen, winning a World Series feels within reach. But the Mets have plenty of work to do against Atlanta and the Phillies in the top-heavy NL East before a potential October rematch with the Dodgers. We just can’t help looking ahead to a looming showdown with L.A. because that’s how the past 3 1/2 months have played out — a virtual arms race between the two coastal powerhouses.

Signing Alonso brought the Mets’ payroll up to $325 million, second only to the Dodgers’ $386 million tab, and they’re really the only two teams that are completely unfettered when it comes to chasing a championship (the Yankees come close at times, but Hal Steinbrenner can’t help but talk about fiscal restraints).

Like the Dodgers they’ve tried to emulate, Cohen and Stearns are empire-building in Queens, and it’s a partnership that seemingly grows stronger by the day.

“We’re not ignoring the Dodgers,” Stearns said. “We understand who they are in our game right now and the success they’ve had, and that’s great. But our primary focus needs to be on ourselves.”

That plan seems to be paying off so far.

David Lennon is an award-winning columnist, a voter for baseball’s Hall of Fame and has covered six no-hitters, including two perfect games.

Related Posts

Ronald Acuña Jr. has nothing to say after Braves’ bold Jarred Kelenic move

After starting an atrocious 0-7 on the season, the Atlanta Braves have seemed to turn things around. Although they will have an uphill battle to climb back to t

Red Sox fаnѕ рleаd wіth teаm to releаѕe Mаѕаtаkа Yoѕhіdа from іnjury lіmbo

Parts of the Boston Red Sox’s offense has been slow to start in the first month of the 2025 campaign, and the inconsistency in the bats has some fans asking abo

Bruce Bochy’ѕ ѕіmрle ѕolutіon to Rаngerѕ’ mіѕerаble offenѕіve ѕlumр

Rangers manager Bruce Bochy offers a calm but firm response to his team’s offensive slump, focusing on leadership and adjustments.

Cаrdіnаlѕ front offіce could further аnger fаnѕ іf they took thіѕ deаdlіne ѕtrаtegy

The Cardinals front office promised a transition period but this could delay that plan even further

Red Sox 10, Blue Jаyѕ 2: Boѕton аmbuѕheѕ Toronto wіth а quіntet of home runѕ

The Red Sox hit five home runs in the first three innings tonight. The Blue Jays haven’t hit five home runs in a series since last summer.

Wіlly Adаmeѕ reveаlѕ Buѕter Poѕey’ѕ crucіаl іmраct іn Gіаntѕ free аgency decіѕіon

Willy Adames explained the impact that Buster Posey had on his decision to sign with the Giants in MLB free agency.