Garrett Crochet explains why signing a Red Sox extension isn’t a slam dunk

FORT MYERS, Fla. — Garrett Crochet, fresh off a blockbuster winter trade, threw his first pitches in a Red Sox uniform on a back field at Fenway South earlier this week. Now, all attention will turn to the organization’s attempts to sign him to a long-term contract.

It’s no secret that the Red Sox, after giving up four good prospects (including top-50 types Kyle Teel and Braden Montgomery) to acquire Crochet from the White Sox in December, badly want their control over the left-hander to extend past 2026, when he’s set for free agency. By January, the sides had begun talks on a long-term deal, setting the table for things to heat up once everyone arrived in southwest Florida. Crochet offered a stark reminder Wednesday, though, that an extension is no foregone conclusion.

“There’s always pros and cons to everything,” Crochet said about his mindset regarding talks. “I think that the long-term security is definitely something attractive. As players, we like to look out for our family first. But with last year being my first taste of starting, part of me also wants to see what I could do with the full season of innings workload.

“(I) was on a short leash. Part of me wants to see what I could do in a full season before, I suppose, locking myself into a certain bracket of player.”

Crochet, who turns 26 in June, broke out with the White Sox last season in his first season as a big league starter, turning in a 3.58 ERA and 2.69 FIP in 146 innings while striking out 209 batters (12.9 K/9) in an All-Star campaign. Seemingly overnight, he went from a rehabbing reliever to one of baseball’s best young starters and Chicago capitalized by aggressively shopping him both at the trade deadline and after the season.

Teams with interest in acquiring Crochet went into talks with the White Sox knowing that he was amenable to extension talks with whichever club got him. The first evidence of that came last summer when Crochet, citing concerns about workload and injury risk (coming off Tommy John surgery in April 2022), made it clear to interested contenders that he would only pitch in the postseason (or go back to the bullpen) if he got an extension in conjunction with a trade.

Crochet’s injury history and lack of track record as a major league starter would seem to make him someone who is open to locking in generational money now. But his comments Wednesday served as a warning that it’s dangerous to pencil him in as signed before a deal gets done. Ahead of what could be another breakout season for the lefty — Vegas odds cast Crochet as having the second-best chance to win the American League Cy Young award — there’s a world in which he bets on himself in search of a bigger deal next winter or on the open market in two years.

There’s likely common ground for both the Sox and Crochet, as his relative youth may allow him to sign a high-dollar deal now, then hit free agency in search of a big payday around age 30. The club, which has little in the way of youthful, top-line pitching in the organization, does seem intent on making it a priority to secure Crochet, who chief baseball officer Craig Breslow has already described as a “bonafide ace.”

“(We’ll) obviously talk about who we are and what we’re all about,” said manager Alex Cora. “At the end of the day, that’s the people upstairs with him. Obviously, it was a big trade and we’d love for him to be part of this for a long time. We know this is a business and it takes two to tango.”

Crochet’s early impressions of the organization have been strong. After spending the first five years of his professional career in one place, the 2020 first-round pick traveled to Boston to meet with team officials shortly after the trade, then returned to town to meet teammates at Fenway Fest in mid-January. Through conversations at a Celtics game, in the bowels of Fenway Park and now in the clubhouse at JetBlue Park, Crochet has begun to feel at home.

“As soon as I was traded to the Red Sox, I knew that this was a place that I could see myself long-term,“ Crochet said. “When you talk about a storied franchise like this one, it’s one that any player would be lucky to call home for whatever duration of time that may be. It’s not exactly fully in my hands. But I’ve been seeing the big picture since as soon as the trade went through.

“Even going back to (Fenway Fest), it seemed like there was a good group cohesiveness going on already. I didn’t want to come in and be boisterous in any way. I just felt like I was able to fit in, slide right in. Guys were very welcoming from the jump. I had a good group of guys reach out right after the trade went through. I think we got off on the right foot and just proceeded accordingly.”

In short order, the Red Sox and Crochet’s representatives will sit down and get down to business when it comes to his future. Things will certainly heat up before Opening Day. For now, Crochet’s sole focus is on first live batting practice session of camp, which is set for Thursday.

“My understanding of it is that Mission 1 was getting to camp and then, talks would happen or not happen after that,“ Crochet said. ”As far as that side of things, I like to leave it to my agent. I just like to come out here and focus on playing ball.”

  • BETTING: Check out our MA sports betting guide, where you can learn basic terminology, definitions and how to read odds for those interested in learning how to bet in Massachusetts.
  • Upgrading infield defense — once again — a spring training goal for Red Sox | Sean McAdam
  • Fenway Insider: Have Red Sox made headway with Garrett Crochet extension?
  • Red Sox World Series odds: Can pitching additions propel Boston into the playoffs?
  • Will Red Sox’ Ceddanne Rafaela stick to one position in 2025?
  • After a year in spotlight, Red Sox’ Brayan Bello focused on improvement

If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

Related Posts

Dave Dombrowski pours cold water on hopes of late spring training signings

Spring training has begun. Philadelphia Phillies pitchers and catchers reported to camp on Feb. 11 and had their first workout on Feb. 12. The Phillies will try

Breaking: More on competing in Orioles camp as pitchers and catchers report today

SARASOTA, Fla. – The due date has arrived for Orioles pitchers and catchers. They’re required to report today unless they have visa issues. There’s usually one in…

Breaking: Eight Orioles spring training games airing on MASN

SARASOTA, Fla. – Eight of the Orioles’ spring training games will air on MASN, exceeding last year’s total by one. The eight games are an even split…

OFFICIAL: Nine Orioles announced as spring training coaches

SARASOTA, Fla. – Nick Markakis and Zack Britton have returned to the Orioles – to serve as spring training guest coaches. They aren’t making a comeback. Nine…

BREAKING: David Stearns all but ruling out Mets return for Jose Iglesias

In his initial press conference of spring training, Stearns on Wednesday indicated that it’s unlikely the free agent will return.

BREAKING NEWS: Mets finalize Pete Alonso deal and re-sign injured reliever Drew Smith

NEW YORK (AP) – Pete Alonso and the New York Mets finalized their $54 million, two-year contract on Wednesday as spring training opened in Florida with the…