Braves GM on replacing Orlando Arcia at shortstop

Of all the holes the Braves needed to fill this offseason, the outfield was by far the most glaring. Alex Anthopoulos addressed that by signing All-Star switch-hitter Jurickson Profar to a three-year contract on Thursday.

Behind the outfield, the pitching staff is still a concern. The rotation could use another proven option, but the bullpen really needs some TLC. The Braves are down two of their top arms from 2024 and have yet to make a single worthwhile addition. A.J. Minter signed with the Mets this week, and Joe Jimenez is expected to miss most of the 2025 campaign after undergoing knee surgery.

The final hole that could be addressed is shortstop. Orlando Arcia, while above average defensively, is the one black hole in an otherwise prolific lineup when healthy. The Braves must find a long-term answer at the position, but that’s a need that seems to be on hold for now, according to general manager Alex Anthopoulos.

#Braves’ Anthopoulos: “We went into last season thinking Orlando (Arcia) would hit 8, 9. You’re now in that spot where, with everyone healthy, you’re looking at him in the 9-hole and 1 through 8 is a lot of really established guys that have a chance to be very, very strong.”

— David O’Brien (@DOBrienATL) January 24, 2025

Eventually, the Braves need to get serious about aggressively attempting to replace Orlando Arcia. He’s not a starting-caliber everyday player, and he’s not getting any younger.

The issue with that is shortstops are not cheap. It’s the most important position on the diamond, and the good ones are going to cost $150+ million in free agency. That’s not a place the Braves have gone in the past with any free agent, but they may have to consider it in the future if Orlando Arcia can’t improve in 2025.

Of course, the Braves do have an internal option in Nacho Alvarez, who made his MLB debut in 2024. However, he struggled mightily at the plate, and there are concerns about his ability to play shortstop long-term. Outside of Alvarez, no shortstop prospect is even close to knocking on the door of the majors. So, while the Braves will put the position on the back-burner for now, it could be the top priority for the club next offseason.

Photo: Jeff Robinson/Icon Sportswire

Related Posts

🚨 BREAKING: The Minnesota Twins have made an official roster move after Royce Lewis was placed on the injured list—an unfortunate setback for one of their most electric young stars. This isn’t just a routine adjustment… it’s a moment that could test the Twins’ depth and resilience early. With Lewis sidelined, the pressure shifts to the rest of the lineup to step up and keep momentum alive.

Minneapolis, MN — It was a brutal stretch for the Minnesota Twins, and it only got worse after a disappointing 10–4 collapse against the Toronto Blue Jays….

🚨 BREAKING: Chipper Jones has officially been crowned an “Immortal Icon,” as the Atlanta Braves lock in a $18.5M lifetime deal—sending waves of emotion through Braves Nation. Some legends don’t walk away… they become part of the franchise forever. Three decades of loyalty, unforgettable swings, and defining moments didn’t just build a career—they built Atlanta’s identity. Now, this honor doesn’t close the book on Chipper’s legacy—it elevates it to something timeless.

For the Atlanta Braves, greatness has often been defined not just by championships or statistics, but by continuity—the rare and enduring connection between a player and a…

Povich delivers a statement performance on the mound while Alonso finally breaks through at the plate, powering the Baltimore Orioles to a confident 6–2 win over the San Francisco Giants. It wasn’t just a victory—it felt like a glimpse of what this team can be when both pitching and offense click at the right time. Momentum might be starting to build in Baltimore… and the league should be watching 👀🔥

Baltimore, MD — The Baltimore Orioles delivered one of their most complete performances of the young 2026 season, defeating the San Francisco Giants 6–2 at Camden Yards…

🚨 BOMBSHELL WHITE SOX CALL UP HOT-HITTING PROSPECT SAM ANTONACCI AMID OFFENSIVE STRUGGLES, insiders reveal the move is a bold attempt to shake up the lineup and bring a much-needed spark to the offense, with Antonacci’s performance in the minors making waves, fans are eager to see if he can make an immediate impact at the MLB level 👇👇👇

Getty MIAMI, FLORIDA – MARCH 16: Sam Antonacci #10 of Team Italy makes a play at shortstop to get out Jackson Chourio #1 of Team Venezuela at…

🚨 BOMBSHELL RED SOX PROBLEM’S ONLY SOLUTION IS TRADING JARREN DURAN, insiders reveal the young outfielder’s struggles have become a major roadblock for the team, with many believing a trade could be the best way to shake things up and bring in fresh talent, fans are divided over whether moving Duran is the right call 👇👇👇

Red Sox Face a Major Dilemma: The Only Solution Is Trading Jarren Duran The Boston Red Sox are facing a significant problem as they try to find…

🚨 BOMBSHELL RED SOX REVEAL WHAT SPARKED RANGER SUAREZ’S BREAKOUT PERFORMANCE AGAINST CARDINALS, insiders say the sudden shift in his game has stunned fans and analysts alike, with Suarez showing signs of becoming a dominant force in the rotation, this breakthrough could be the turning point the Red Sox desperately needed 👇👇👇

The Boston Red Sox got exactly what they needed from left-handed starting pitcher Ranger Surez on Saturday. Surez made his third start in a Red Sox jersey…