BREAKING: Should The Yankees Target Tyler Matzek to Fill Lefty Reliever Spot?

Apr 1, 2024; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Atlanta Braves relief pitcher Tyler Matzek (68) pitches against the Chicago White Sox during the ninth inning at Guaranteed Rate Field. Mandatory Credit: Kamil Krzaczynski-Imagn Images
Should the Yankees take a chance on lefty reliever Tyler Matzek who is slated to throw a showcase in front of scouts on Thursday?

With the New York Yankees needing a left-handed reliever for their bullpen, a reunion with Tim Hill makes sense.

But if they don’t bring back Hill, could this veteran lefty be a potential replacement option for the Yankees?

MLB insider Jon Morosi of MLB Network reported on Wednesday that veteran reliever Tyler Matzek will throw a showcase for scouts on Thursday in Irvine, California with hopes that a team across the league will sign him after being limited to just 10 innings across the past two seasons.

Matzek, 34, was sidelined for all of the 2023 season and returned to make just 11 appearances in 2024, allowing 11 earned runs in the process (9.90 ERA).

After beginning the 2022 campaign with a 5.06 ERA, he was placed on the injured list on May 17 with shoulder inflammation and did not return until July 4. Despite making 42 appearances in 2022 going 4-2 with a 3.50 ERA across 43.2 innings, Matzek was left off the NLDS roster for the Braves after experiencing elbow discomfort. He would later need Tommy John Surgery which also kept him out of the entire 2023 season.

Matzek signed a minor league deal with the San Francisco Giants on July 29, 2024. But after posting a 5.79 ERA across three outings for the Giants’ Triple-A affiliate, the Sacramento River Cats, he was released by the organization on August 30.

The Braves brought back Matzek shortly thereafter, signing him to a minor league on August 31.

Despite his injury history over the last few seasons, Matzek’s career numbers are still impressive and when healthy, he can be a reliable bullpen arm and long reliever as well. He also has experience as a starting pitcher.

Matzek was one of the Braves’ best relievers in 2021, helping them capture their first World Series title since 1995.

In 168 career games (24 starts) pitching for both the Braves and Colorado Rockies, Matzek has gone 16-21 with a 3.72 ERA and has 272 strikeouts across 285.1 innings with a WHIP of 1.36.

With the Yankees bullpen currently having no lefty options for the 2025 season, Matzek could become a candidate if he impresses scouts during his showcase on Thursday.

Signing Matzek would be the type of low-risk, high-reward move New York could certainly make.

As sources told Pat Ragazzo of Yankees On SI, another former Yankee reliever, Lou Trivino, threw a bullpen session in Palm Beach, Fla. in front of scouts on Tuesday. The Yankees, Los Angeles Dodgers, Cleveland Guardians, Chicago Cubs, San Francisco Giants, Kansas City Royals and Cincinnati Reds were among those in attendance.

Trivino is an additional reunion candidate for the Yankees and scouts were said to have come away impressed with his bullpen session, which saw the righty hit 94 mph on his sinker. Like Matzek, Trivino, 33, has essentially missed the last two years of action due to Tommy John surgery in 2022.

Related Posts

Why Braves must trade for Twins’ Joe Ryan

A breakdown of why Twins starting pitcher Joe Ryan makes sense as a trade candidate for the Braves this offseason.

Yankees Excited by Left-Handed Reliever’s Potential

After displaying immense upside in his first year with the New York Yankees, the organization is optimistic about what Brent Headrick could bring to the table i

💥 JUST IN: Cubs president Jed Hoyer delivers a powerful and unmistakable message about Chicago’s offseason direction igniting a wave of speculation as fans and analysts try to decode what bold moves might reshape the roster for a defining 2026 run

The Chicago Cubs have their approach for the offseason set, and it revolves around improving he pitching staff as a whole.

Baseball Breaking News: Red Sox in Talks to Trade 6’2″, 250-Pound No. 2 Prospect for Ace Tarik Skubal — Boston’s Stunning Pitching Shake-Up Sends Shockwaves Across MLB

In a development that has lit up the baseball world like a July fireworks show, the Boston Red Sox are reportedly deep in negotiations on a blockbuster…

🔥 INSIDE THE BLUEPRINT: ChiSoxFanMike Unveils a Bold, Season-Defining White Sox Offseason Plan That Could Rewrite Chicago’s Future — From Surprise Trades to Franchise-Changing Moves, Fans Are Buzzing About the Vision That Might Finally Spark a True Southside Rebuild

A 2026 White Sox offseason plan featuring roster analysis, trades, free-agent targets, payroll strategy, and data-driven information.

🔥 TRADE FEVER RISING: The Atlanta Braves are being linked to the perfect blockbuster offer for Twins ace Pablo López — a bold, calculated move that could supercharge their 2026 rotation and leave the rest of MLB scrambling to keep up.

Atlanta Braves perfect trade offer for Minnesota Twins pitcher Pablo Lopez includes top prospects and international signing pool allocation details analysis.