With the offseason looming on the horizon, the Baltimore Orioles are gearing up for some pivotal decisions before the frenzy of free agency kicks in.

After promising strides over the past couple of seasons, the Birds are sitting at a critical juncture where refining the rotation and adding a right-handed powerhouse to the batting line-up take precedence.

The buzz among the fans is palpable—Baltimore is yearning for postseason triumphs, and the heat is on for David Rubenstein and GM Mike Elias to deliver just that.

The offseason promises to be a test of Elias’ strategic prowess. Will the Orioles splash the cash to retain their marquee players, or will they delve into their treasure trove of prospects to exchange for premium talent? Here’s where Elias will be put to the test this winter with issues that could shape the franchise’s trajectory:

Replacing the Irreplaceable: Corbin Burnes

The acquisition of Corbin Burnes has undeniably been a coup for the Orioles, cementing his spot as one of the league’s top aces this past season. But as he eyes free agency with Scott Boras at the negotiating helm, Burnes is set to command figures beyond $200 million. With such outstanding performances under his belt, Burnes undoubtedly deserves the payday, but is Elias ready to meet those demands?

Historically, Elias isn’t renowned for lavish spending sprees, making it unlikely for Baltimore to engage in a financial wrangle for Burnes, potentially the priciest pitcher in the market this winter. Pivoting towards acquiring a potential star like Sonny Gray via trade might offer the Orioles cost-efficient flexibility without the risk of long-term commitments.

The Decision on James McCann

James McCann stands at the crossroads in Baltimore, with his retention hinging largely on the future plans for budding talent Samuel Basallo. While McCann’s leadership has been invaluable, the Orioles are unlikely to hold onto his current contract’s hefty price tag.

They’ll be on the lookout for someone to back up Adley Rutschman come 2025, gauging Basallo’s readiness after a challenging end to the 2024 season at Triple-A.

For a team that promises increased payroll, retaining McCann could be judicious. His presence in the locker room could stabilize and nurture a young roster hungry for continuity and mentorship. But whether the Orioles’ front office concurs with this notion remains uncertain.

Coby Mayo’s Trade Prospects

Coby Mayo has long been in the thick of trade deliberations, especially after an electrifying year in Triple-A that had fans labeling him untouchable.

Yet, his initial major league stint did little to fortify that stance.

If the Orioles opt to trade Mayo, it will likely be for a significant return. Despite rookie challenges, his potential still screams major league star.

Elias may view trading Mayo as the price of competing for a championship in 2025, especially considering the departures of Burnes and Anthony Santander.

With the club’s depth and Jordan Westburg breaking through, Mayo’s future could pivot the Orioles towards acquiring top-tier pitching talent—perhaps targeting the Mariners if the right deal is in the offing.

What’s Next for Jackson Holliday?

Forecasting the 2025 lineup, Jackson Holliday appears as a key fixture. Yet, his debut season left much to be desired, marking a disappointing .189/.255/.311 slash line.

As the Orioles eye the next season, the pressure mounts on Holliday to convert his potential into performance.

Baltimore seems poised to give Holliday another shot as the starting second baseman come Opening Day. But the organization must be ready with alternatives if setbacks persist.

The depth within the organization, led by possible substitutions like Jorge Mateo, will require strategic foresight to navigate Holliday’s developmental curve, ensuring the Orioles aren’t left exposed if the foundational piece of their future struggles to solidify his place.