Cubs blockbuster trade idea swaps Nico Hoerner for Padres 3-time All-Star | Sporting News

The trade rumors around Chicago Cubs second baseman Nico Hoerner seem to have quieted down from earlier this offseason. Might a deal still happen?

Hoerner, a 27-year-old Gold Glove second baseman, was extended through the 2026 season by the Cubs a couple years ago. But with top infield prospect Matt Shaw clamoring for playing time, Hoerner looked to be on the trade block–until third baseman Isaac Paredes was shipped off instead.

If the Cubs were to trade Hoerner still, one would have to think it would be for an offensive upgrade somewhere on the infield. Shaw can also play second and first baseman Michael Busch can shift to third, so there’s flexibility with where that new infielder would play.

Luis Arraez of the San Diego Padres, meanwhile, has been constantly discussed as a trade candidate this winter with his team potentially looking to shed payroll. Could the two be swapped for one another?

Recently, John Perrotto of Draft Nation proposed a deal that would ship Hoerner to the Padres for Arraez, who will make $14 million this season, and surprisingly, three other San Diego players.

“How about if Cubs trade middle infielder Nico Hoerner to the Padres for infielder Luis Arraez, right-handed reliever Jeremiah Estrada and two Class A prospects – left-hander Kash Mayfield and shortstop Cobb Hightower?” Perrotto wrote.

“The three-time batting champion Arraez could fill the hole for the Cubs vacated by Hoerner at second base. It would allow the Padres to shed his $14-million salary in order free money for the two years and $23.5 million left on Hoerner’s contract.”

It’s an interesting value proposition to think of Hoerner being worth more than Arraez alone. Sure, he racks up more slightly more WAR than Arraez and has an extra year of team control, but Arraez is a three-time batting champion and an All-Star all three years.

Arraez is a .323 career hitter, but he doesn’t walk much or hit for much power. He’s a better hitter than Hoerner, but the latter steals bases and plays fantastic defense, while the former is best off playing first base or designated hitter.

It’s an interesting trade idea, but asking San Diego to attach prospects feels overly ambitious. However, one never knows what ideas might be running through a front office’s collective brain.

More MLB: Yankees deemed favorites to land $195 million superstar thanks to Cubs’ latest gaffe

Related Posts

🚨 BREAKING: Just 12 Hours After Being Released by the Phillies, One of MLB’s Top Hitters Shocks the League by Turning Down $60M From Red Sox to Join the Yankees for $50M, Fans Across New York Are Ecstatic, Analysts Debate the Massive Impact on the AL East 👀👇👇👇

Just 12 hours after being released by the Philadelphia Phillies, one of the most feared and respected hitters in MLB made a decision that instantly sent shockwaves…

🚨 BREAKING: Chicago Cubs Re-Sign Recently Released 10-Year MLB Veteran Just Before Game Against Reds, Fans Are Ecstatic About the Surprise Return, Analysts Debate How This Could Impact the Team’s Early Season Momentum 👀👇👇👇

Getty LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA – APRIL 25: Vince Velasquez #56 of the Chicago Cubs pitches in relief during the eighth inning during the game against the Los…

🚨BASEBALL WORLD LEFT HEARTBROKEN: Sandy Koufax has reportedly shocked fans everywhere after revealing serious heart problems at the age of 90. This isn’t just a Dodgers legend… it’s one of the most iconic figures the sport has ever seen, and messages of love, prayers, and support are now pouring in from across the baseball world 🤍🙏👇👇👇

News circulating today has stunned the American and global baseball community as pitcher Sandy Koufax reportedly revealed a health issue related to heart disease at age 90….

🚨PRESSURE IS EXPLODING AROUND THE RED SOX: Chad Tracy has reportedly stepped in to defend Jarren Duran as tension and criticism surrounding Boston continue to rise. This isn’t just about one player struggling under the spotlight… it’s about the crushing pressure that comes with wearing a Red Sox uniform, and emotions inside the organization may be reaching a dangerous level 👀👇👇👇

BREAKING: “I’m disappointed in myself” – Red Sox’s number one pitching gem collapses after Tommy John surgery The future, once considered one of the greatest hopes of…

🚨PRESSURE IS EXPLODING AROUND THE RED SOX: Chаd Trаcy hаѕ reрortedly ѕteррed іn to defend Jаrren Durаn аѕ tenѕіon аnd crіtіcіѕm ѕurroundіng Boѕton contіnue to rіѕe. Thіѕ іѕn’t juѕt аbout one рlаyer ѕtrugglіng under the ѕрotlіght… іt’ѕ аbout the cruѕhіng рreѕѕure thаt comeѕ wіth weаrіng а Red Sox unіform, аnd emotіonѕ іnѕіde the orgаnіzаtіon mаy be reаchіng а dаngerouѕ level 👀👇👇👇

The Boѕtoп Red ѕox fап bаѕe wаѕ throwп іпto апother wаve of emotіoп аfter а drаmаtіc ѕtаtemeпt аttrіbυted to іпterіm mапаger Chаd Trаcy begап cіrcυlаtіпg oпlіпe, defeпdіпg…

🚨DODGERS FANS ARE STUNNED: Shohei Ohtani reportedly delivered the most dominant pitching performance of his Dodgers career—only for Los Angeles to still let the game slip away. This wasn’t just another great outing… it was pure superstar brilliance wasted, and frustration across the fanbase is reaching another level as questions continue to surround the team’s support around their generational talent 👀👇👇👇

Shohei Ohtani completed seven innings on only 89 pitches — the deepest he’s gone in a start since pitching a shutout on July 27, 2023 with the…