Report: 2 New Year’s resolutions for the 2025 Baltimore Orioles

Sep 25, 2024; Bronx, New York, USA; Baltimore Orioles shortstop Gunnar Henderson (2) breaks his bat hitting a single against the New York Yankees during the first inning at Yankee Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-Imagn Images

Well, we’ve just about made it through 2024. In just a few short hours, we’ll be moving into 2025 and…almost nothing will have changed.

Maybe you’ll have some short-term lifestyle changes take effect, or maybe you’ll go a bit bigger and enact something more beneficial from a long-term perspective. I’ve made a few successful changes over the past couple years that have put me in a much better spot than I had been previously.

But what about the Orioles? Well, it’s been a very slow couple weeks since the announced signings of Tyler O’Neill

and Gary Sanchez. Outside of the Orioles missing out on the top tier of available free agents, there hasn’t been a ton in the way of actual news or transactions. The O’s have made a couple interesting minor league deals, including picking up former top prospect Jordyn Adams, but there hasn’t been much of note for a few weeks.

So, with the new year quickly approaching the Orioles are resigned to working the trade market for a top starting pitcher, if that’s something they’re interested in. What else outside of that will the O’s be focused on? Here are a few ideas, a couple things the Orioles can resolve to change in 2025.

Return to the playoffs and actually win in October

The last time the Orioles won a playoff game was Game 3 of the 2014 ALDS against the Tigers. They were subsequently swept in that year’s ALCS and have now run their October losing streak to 10 games. We’d love to see that change in 2025.

It’ll be a difficult battle to get back to the playoffs for the third year in a row, there’s no doubt about that. With the Yankees and Red Sox taking big swings in free agency and the trade market, the AL East is going to be a rock fight all year. It’ll take a lot for the O’s to capture the division title, but they’re in a good spot roster-wise and should hopefully be able to leverage their star power into another successful year.

But they can’t afford to get swept out of the playoffs again. If we have to deal with the narrative that this team isn’t built to win in October or some nonsense in that vein, it’ll be a really challenging winter heading into 2026.

Sign Gunnar Henderson to a contract extension

Is this a realistic option? Well, Henderson is a Scott Boras client so it certainly won’t be easy. But there are top stars, like Bobby Witt Jr. and Fernando Tatis Jr., who agreed to massive contract extensions well before hitting free agency.

Henderson is currently slated to hit free agency after the 2028 season. From Mike Elias’ perspective, you want to take advantage of these team-friendly contract years while you have them. But if you want to keep someone like Henderson around, and his performance to this point suggests that the Orioles absolutely should want to keep this guy in Baltimore for the rest of his career, you probably need to start laying that groundwork now.

Did Juan Soto break the market for top stars? Maybe. Would Henderson be willing to make a deal like the one Witt has, in the neighborhood of $300 million? Maybe, maybe not. He’s currently 23 and is slated to hit free agency at 27, a year older than Juan Soto is now. But there’s also a lot of uncertainty regarding the future of MLB’s local broadcasting revenue, and there’s a real chance we get a lockout or a strike after the expiration of the current collective bargaining agreement in 2026. Maybe that makes Henderson a bit more likely to take a long-term deal now, rather than wait and test his luck.

It would probably take $350 million, maybe more, to lock Henderson up for the foreseeable future. Despite the cost, he’s an elite player who’s shown no signs of slowing down, and he’s still super young. There’s very little risk in locking a player like that up for 12+ years. This one is a big IF, but it should be right at the top of the list for Mike Elias and company.

Related Posts

OFFSEASON MOVE ALERT: The Atlanta Braves quietly added a veteran reliever on a one year deal while the rest of the league was watching bigger headlines. The timing of this signing is raising questions about what’s coming next. Insiders believe this move is not as simple as it looks. The Braves may be setting up something far more calculated.

The Atlanta Braves have quietly assembled one of the more deliberate and calculated offseasons in baseball, and Saturday marked another significant step as the organization moved to…

Update: Twins, Joe Ryan headed to arbitration over $500K salary gap

Twins, Joe Ryan Headed to Arbitration After $500,000 Gap at Deadline A relatively small financial gap proved large enough to send the Minnesota Twins and right-handed starter…

Update: The memory of Danny Coulombe’s clutch performances is still fresh, but in Baltimore, past success doesn’t guarantee a future role. As the Orioles shape their roster, they face a choice between loyalty and evolution—bringing him back for continuity or moving on for a sharper, future-focused plan. This decision could reveal more about the team’s identity than any single signing.

Orioles Mailbag: Why Baltimore Isn’t Reuniting with Danny Coulombe and How Mutual Options Really Work As the Baltimore Orioles continue shaping their roster for the upcoming season,…

⚾ Orioles Bring Stability to a Winter of Uncertainty: Gunnar Henderson and Adley Rutschman Lead Six Key Players in Signing 2026 Contracts, Sending a Clear Message of Confidence and Setting the Foundation for the Franchise’s Future

In his first year of arbitration eligibility, the Orioles and shortstop Gunnar Henderson agreed on a 2026 salary of $8.5 million. That’s the largest salary for an…

💥 MLB TWIST NOBODY SAW COMING: The Los Angeles Dodgers’ Aggressive Push for Kyle Tucker Suddenly Hits a Major Roadblock as Troubling New Details Emerge—A Setback That Could Quietly Alter the Dodgers’ Entire Championship Blueprint.

The Los Angeles Dodgers are going to enter the 2026 MLB season looking to three-peat as champions. So far this offseason, they have been talked about a lot in…

💥 AFTER 16 SEASONS, A TURNING POINT ARRIVES: Freddіe Freemаn Mаkeѕ а Quіet but Powerful Cаreer Decіѕіon—One Thаt Sendѕ а Cleаr Sіgnаl About Whаt’ѕ Comіng Next for the Loѕ Angeleѕ Dodgerѕ аnd Leаveѕ Fаnѕ Reаdіng Between the Lіneѕ.

The Loѕ аngeleѕ Dodgerѕ cарtured theіr ѕecond ѕtrаіght World ѕerіeѕ tіtle іn 2025, fueled by the conѕіѕtency of theіr veterаn core, іncludіng fіrѕt bаѕemаnFreddіe Freemаn. The 36-yeаr-old left-hаnded ѕlugger hаѕ…