Discuss!! Should the Cowboys consider drafting a quarterback in the first round to replace Dak?

Should the Cowboys Draft a First-Round Quarterback to Replace Dak Prescott?

Dak Prescott addresses contract talks, lawsuit | Reuters

The Dallas Cowboys find themselves at a crossroads. After another season where expectations fell short of reality, the conversation among fans and analysts has shifted to a controversial topic: Should the Cowboys consider drafting a quarterback in the first round to replace Dak Prescott?

Dak’s Current Status

Dak Prescott swaps water bottles for Red Bull, brings the energy to  primetime

Dak Prescott, the face of the franchise since 2016, has delivered solid performances year after year. However, critics point to his struggles in key playoff moments and his inability to lead the Cowboys to the Super Bowl as reasons for a potential change. While Prescott has shown flashes of brilliance, some argue that his ceiling might not be high enough to propel Dallas to championship glory.

The Case for Drafting a QB

  1. Long-Term Planning: Prescott is entering the later stages of his prime. Drafting a young quarterback could allow the Cowboys to groom a successor and ensure long-term stability at the position.
  2. Cap Management: Prescott’s contract takes up a significant portion of the salary cap. A rookie quarterback on a manageable deal could free up resources to address other areas of need.
  3. Fresh Leadership: A new quarterback could bring a fresh perspective and energy to the team, potentially shaking off years of postseason disappointment.

The Case Against It

  1. Dak’s Proven Abilities: Prescott remains one of the more reliable quarterbacks in the league. Replacing him with an unproven rookie could set the franchise back.
  2. Immediate Needs Elsewhere: The Cowboys have other pressing needs, such as bolstering the offensive line and secondary. Using a first-round pick on a quarterback might not align with their current roster dynamics.
  3. Locker Room Stability: Prescott is a respected leader. Introducing a quarterback controversy could disrupt team chemistry and create unnecessary distractions.

Fan Reactions

Sam Hodde/Getty Images

The debate has already ignited strong opinions across social media:

“Drafting a QB in the first round would be a huge mistake. Dak is still the guy,” one fan tweeted.

Another countered, “We’ve had enough of mediocrity. It’s time to roll the dice on a new franchise QB.”

What Will Jerry Jones Do?

As always, the decision rests with team owner Jerry Jones and the Cowboys’ front office. Whether they double down on Prescott or take a bold swing in the draft, the choice will undoubtedly shape the franchise’s future.

What do you think? Should the Cowboys stick with Dak or roll the dice on a first-round quarterback? Share your thoughts using #CowboysDraftDebate.

Related Posts

🚨BREAKING: Should the 49ers and Deebo Samuel run it back — and is a reunion with the ‘wide back’ closer than anyone thinks? With shifting offensive priorities and unfinished business lingering from past playoff runs, the possibility of bringing Deebo back into the fold has sparked serious debate inside the fanbase. 👇👇👇

Should the San Francisco 49ers and Deebo Samuel Run It Back? 4 The idea of a reunion in professional sports is always seductive. Familiarity breeds nostalgia. Nostalgia…

STEELERS NATION, BARNWELL JUST WENT NUCLEAR: The ESPN analyst is absolutely RIDICULING Pittsburgh’s obsession with Aaron Rodgers, calling their entire approach ‘ENTIRELY INCURIOUS’ – is this brutal takedown the wake-up call that exposes a desperate front office… or the harsh truth that could bury their 2026 hopes before the season even starts?!

  As the Pittsburgh Steelers hit the road for the 2026 NFL Scouting Combine in Indianapolis this week, much of the team’s focus still seems to center…

STEELERS NATION, WAKE UP: Kaboly just called out THIS Steeler as the guy getting PAID WAY TOO MUCH – and he’s now the prime candidate to become Pittsburgh’s next shocking cap casualty that could quietly reshape their entire roster this offseason!

For Pittsburgh Steelers inside linebacker Malik Harrison, the two-year contract he signed ahead of the 2025 season might instead turn into a one-year stay. With a new…

49ERS NATION, BREAKING IN SAN FRANCISCO: Nick Bosa just SHOCKED everyone by completely transforming his look during the NFL offseason – is this the savage new edge-rusher vibe that turns him into an even more UNSTOPPABLE force in 2026?!

San Francisco, CA – In a surprising twist during the NFL offseason, San Francisco 49ers defensive end Nick Bosa has debuted a fresh new look, sparking a…

49ERS NATION, THEY JUST GOT DANGEROUSLY FAST! This jaw-dropping 4th-round steal at the NFL Combine just handed Brock Purdy a blazing NEW deep-threat weapon that will make every secondary TERRIFIED to sleep on San Francisco’s offense!

‘I feel the need… the need for speed.’ San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan fully admitted his team needed to get faster when he spoke to…

BREAKING: BUFFALO LAND THEIR MISSING PIECE! Former Super Bowl champion LB, a tackling MACHINE with a 10.3% run-stop rate (TOP 4% IN THE NFL)!!!

In a move that’s sure to send shockwaves through the AFC East, the Buffalo Bills have officially signed former Philadelphia Eagles linebacker Nakobe Dean to a multi-year…