New York Yankees rumor claims Cody Bellinger trade talks have stalled again, team may pivot to chase for 5 specific stars

A fresh New York Yankees rumor suggests that despite reports of talks on a Cody Bellinger trade nearing the finish line, discussions have stalled once again.

This has been a busy last week for the Yankees. Over the first few weeks of the offseason, the organization was completely focused on trying to re-sign superstar outfielder Juan Soto. However, despite their best efforts and an offer for as much as $760 million, the team lost one of their most important players to the New York Mets.

Related: New York Yankees, Chicago Cubs ‘deep into talks’ on blockbuster trade for All-Star

There had been speculation for quite some time about what the team could do in the event they lost the Soto chase. Well, in the fallout of the 26-year-old going to the Mets, the Yanks have made a pair of big moves. The first was giving Atlanta Braves star pitcher Max Fried a massive $218 million deal. Then they made a bold trade for, arguably, the best closer in MLB — Milwaukee Brewers stud Devin Williams.

On Saturday, a new report suggested that their next major move would be completing a long-rumored trade for Chicago Cubs outfielder Cody Bellinger. However, on Sunday New York Post MLB insider Jon Heyman suggested that those talks may have hit a wall. And the New York Yankees could soon pivot to five different players to fill their void at first base.

  • Cody Bellinger stats (2024): .266 AVG, .325 OBP, .426 SLG, .751 OPS, 18 HR, 78 RBI, 72 R

Money again holding up completion of Cody Bellinger trade to New York Yankees

New York Yankees rumor claims Cody Bellinger trade talks have stalled again, team may pivot to chase for 5 specific stars
Credit: Isaiah J. Downing-Imagn Images

“Still a money gap in Bellinger trade talk with Yankees and Cubs as of this minute,” Heyman wrote on X. “It’s a matter of ‘who blinks first’ if ever.”

The outfielder/first baseman has over $52 million left on his current deal. Many teams around the league have balked at the idea of taking on all of that money after he had a down season in 2024. Most want the Cubs to pick up some of that money. Something they seem uninterested in doing.

  • Cody Bellinger contract: Three years, $80 million

With discussions at a stalemate, Heyman revealed five players New York could pivot to during their current game of chicken with the Cubbies. “[The trade] still could happen but Yanks also considering Pete Alonso, Christian Walker, Carlos Santana, Josh Naylor, Nathaniel Lowe, and probably others.”

Related: New York Yankees rumors reveal All-Star bat team to make ‘full-court press’ for in coming days

Related Posts

Breaking: Depth moves don’t always grab headlines—but they can shape a season. The Twins bring in Orlando Arcia to bolster shortstop depth. This signing could pay off at the right moment (J)

Minnesota Twins Opt for Experience and Stability Behind Brooks Lee with Low-Risk Signing of Former All-Star Orlando Arcia The Minnesota Twins made a move this week that…

REPORT: Records don’t fall every season—but 2026 might be different. Several Twins players are closing in on major career milestones. These five moments should be on every fan’s radar (J)

Keep These on Your Radar: Five Minnesota Twins Players Chasing Career Milestones in the 2026 Season As the calendar flips to a new year, anticipation around Major…

REPORT: Minnesota hit the reset button at the trade deadline. Now, three former Twins free agents are searching for new homes. We predict which teams make the most sense—and why (J)

Where Will Harrison Bader, Willi Castro, and Danny Coulombe Sign This Offseason? The Minnesota Twins sent shockwaves through Major League Baseball last July when they initiated a…

🚨 BREAKING NEWS: Loѕ Angeleѕ Dodgerѕ chаіrmаn Mаrk Wаlter hаѕ juѕt аnnounced thаt the club hаѕ раrtnered wіth а mаjor іnveѕtment grouр on а mаѕѕіve $1.5 bіllіon Dodgerѕ Stаdіum uрgrаde рroject 🏟️.

Dodger ѕtаdіum Reіmаgіned: іnѕіde the $1.5 Bіllіon Vіѕіon Thаt Could Redefіne the Future of Loѕ аngeleѕ Bаѕebаll The Loѕ аngeleѕ Dodgerѕ hаve never been а frаnchіѕe content…

🚨 INSIDER REPORT: Red Sox Ace Gаrrett Crochet Set to Domіnаte іn 2026—Iѕ He Alreаdy the AL Cy Young Fаvorіte? The Shockіng Predіctіon Thаt Hаѕ Fаnѕ on Edge аnd the Leаgue Wаtchіng Cloѕely! 👇👇👇

Gаrrett Crochet: аL Cy Young Contender іn 2026? The Red ѕox аce Could Brіng Home Mаjor Hаrdwаre Wіth the 2026 MLB ѕeаѕon on the horіzon, рredіctіonѕ for…

🚨 EXCLUSIVE: Red Sox Tаrget Trаde for Dodgerѕ’ World Serіeѕ Chаmріon Lefty—Iѕ Thіѕ the Mіѕѕіng Pіece for Theіr Chаmріonѕhір Puѕh? The trаde rumorѕ wіll leаve you gueѕѕіng! 👇👇

ѕhould the Boѕton Red ѕox рurѕue а Trаde for аnthony Bаndа? а Look аt the рotentіаl Deаl аnd іtѕ іmраct аѕ the Boѕton Red ѕox рreраre for…