Red Sox’s Garrett Crochet has nightmare outing against the Twins: A career-worst start leaves fans stunned

The Boston Red Sox entered the 2025 MLB season with high hopes after acquiring Garrett Crochet in a blockbuster trade. The young left-handed pitcher, known for his electric stuff and composure on the mound, was expected to be a key piece of their starting rotation, a legitimate ace to lead the charge. But on Monday night, against the Minnesota Twins, Crochet had a start that he—and every Red Sox fan—will want to quickly forget.

Garrett Crochet’s Worst Start Ever: 13-6 Loss to the Twins

It was supposed to be just another game in the long season, but things went sideways in a hurry for the Red Sox. In the first game of their series against the Twins, Crochet delivered his worst start as a professional, leaving fans and teammates alike stunned. In just 1.2 innings of work, the 24-year-old lefty was shelled for 11 runs (10 earned) on 9 hits, including multiple hard-hit balls. He failed to record a single strikeout and walked three batters. It was a disastrous performance that saw Crochet chased from the mound early, and his night was over before it even had a chance to begin.

The Nightmare Unfolds: A Flurry of Runs

The game was a disaster from the start. Crochet struggled to find his rhythm, with the Twins’ offense capitalizing on nearly every mistake he made. Whether it was leaving pitches up in the zone or failing to get ahead in counts, Crochet couldn’t escape the barrage of hits that came his way. By the time he was pulled from the game, the Red Sox were already down by a seemingly insurmountable margin, with the Twins leading 11-0.

What made this outing even more alarming for Crochet was that he entered the game with a solid 3.12 ERA over his first three starts of the season. He had been viewed as one of the most reliable and consistent starters in the Red Sox rotation, but this performance raised serious concerns. For a pitcher who had been one of the team’s most promising arms, Monday’s outing was a sobering reminder that even the best players can have off-days.

Career-Worst Performance: The Numbers Don’t Lie

For context, Crochet’s performance on Monday night was unlike anything we’ve seen from him before. According to StatMuse, this was the first time in his career that Crochet allowed eight or more earned runs in a game. To make matters worse, his ERA ballooned from 3.12 to 7.58 in just one outing—a staggering increase that puts his previous consistency into sharp contrast. In what was supposed to be a critical year for his development, this could not have come at a worse time for the young lefty.

The Red Sox’s 13-6 loss to the Twins was more than just a poor start; it was a complete meltdown that left the team scrambling. Though the offense did what it could, scoring six runs, it was clear that no amount of runs could have saved them from Crochet’s historic struggles. The team was forced to dig deep into their bullpen to finish out the game, and even though the bullpen kept the Twins from extending their lead further, the damage was already done.

Bouncing Back: What’s Next for Crochet?

While this outing was an undeniable low point in Crochet’s career, it is important to remember that this is just one game in a long season. Bad starts happen in the majors, even to the most talented players, and this rough outing does not define who Crochet is as a pitcher. What will matter now is how he bounces back from this. The key for Crochet will be not allowing this rough start to affect his confidence moving forward.

Crochet has been one of the most exciting young pitchers in the league ever since he became a full-time starter in 2024. His stuff is undeniable—he has the velocity, movement, and control to dominate hitters on any given night. This performance, as difficult as it may have been to endure, should be viewed as a one-off, an unfortunate blip on an otherwise promising career trajectory.

The good news for Crochet and the Red Sox is that they have time to move past this. With his next start coming up in just a few days, Crochet has the opportunity to put this nightmare behind him. There is no reason to believe that he won’t regain his form. He has shown throughout his career that he is mentally tough and capable of shaking off adversity, and that’s exactly what he will need to do here.

A Season of Promise, Not Panic

Despite the severity of his outing, the sky is still the limit for Garrett Crochet. The Red Sox made a significant investment in him, and the young left-hander’s history suggests that he will rebound from this tough loss. He’s shown incredible maturity on the mound, and this rough outing will likely serve as a valuable learning experience as he continues to develop.

Red Sox fans shouldn’t panic just yet. While this loss to the Twins stings, it’s important to keep perspective. Crochet has the ability to be the ace this team needs, and the performance against Minnesota, while disheartening, does not diminish the talent that he brings to the mound every time he steps on it. He will have to shake off this performance and refocus as the season progresses, but there’s no reason to think this will be a trend.

For now, Crochet will look ahead to his next start, determined to right the ship and get back on track. The Red Sox are counting on him to deliver the consistency and dominance that they’ve come to expect, and with his work ethic and skill, there’s no doubt that he’ll do just that.

Conclusion: A Glimpse into the Rollercoaster of a Long MLB Season

In the end, baseball is a sport filled with ups and downs, and Garrett Crochet’s tough night against the Twins was just one of those downs. His journey this season will be full of both highs and lows, but it’s how he responds to this adversity that will ultimately define his season. With a fresh mindset and a determination to improve, Crochet will look to make sure this is the last time fans have to witness a start like Monday night’s.

For now, the Red Sox will move forward, keeping the faith in their ace as he prepares for the next challenge on the horizon. Baseball fans know that the season is long, and the path to success is rarely linear. Crochet’s resilience will be tested, but if there’s one thing we know about the talented lefty, it’s that he’s more than capable of overcoming adversity and turning this tough start into fuel for a stronger finish.