Discussion with Mets about converting Clay Holmes into a starter began at GM meetings last month

DALLAS (AP) – The Mets were in the midst of the general managers meetings in San Antonio last month when Clay Holmes’ agent brought up the idea of converting the two-time All-Star closer back into a starting pitcher for the first time since his rookie season.

“The arsenal should work against both both sides of the plate. He has, we think, the variety of stuff to turn over a lineup multiple times,” Mets president of baseball operations David Stearns said Tuesday, a day after Holmes and New York finalized a $38 million, three-year contract. “You start adding all of those up and that leads you to believe this could be an effective major league starter.”

Holmes gets a $13 million salary in each of the first two seasons of the deal and has a $12 million player option for 2027. The 31-year-old right-hander made his only four big league starts with Pittsburgh in 2018 but made 114 in the minors.

Holmes´ sinker averaged 96.6 mph this season and he threw it 56% of the time, along with 23% sliders and 21% sweepers. Adding a changeup is likely.

“I think the usage is going to change a little bit,” Stearns said. “He may have to introduce some new stuff that we believe he can do. And if he´s able to do that I think we´re going to have someone who´s going to be a very solid contributor in our rotation.”

Holmes developed into a dominant closer with the New York Yankees after he was acquired from the Pirates in July 2021. But he struggled this year with control and allowing hits on soft contact. Holmes lost his closer´s job to Luke Weaver after allowing a game-ending grand slam to Texas rookie Wyatt Langford on Sept. 3.

FILE -New York Yankees pitcher Clay Holmes delivers against the Kansas City Royals during the sixth inning of Game 1 of the American League baseball division series, Saturday, Oct. 5, 2024, in New York. (AP Photo/Frank Franklin II, File)

Holmes was 3-5 with a 3.14 ERA and a career-high 30 saves in 67 appearances, leading the majors with 13 blown saves. Rediscovering his sinker, he became an effective setup man for the AL champion Yankees in the postseason, going 3-1 with a 2.25 ERA in 13 games.

“In this day and age with relievers who continue to refine what they do, frankly with the pitch-design resources that all these guys have in front of them, I think there are frankly a number of relievers that have considered converting, especially those who had started previously in their careers,” Stearns said. “So, no, it didn’t shock me.”

Holmes joins a rotation projected to include right-handers Kodai Senga, Frankie Montas and Paul Blackburn, and left-hander David Peterson.

Runner-up for 2023 NL Rookie of the Year, Senga was limited to one regular-season start and three postseason appearances because of a right shoulder capsule strain, strained left calf and right triceps tightness.

Head athletic trainer Joseph Golia is to travel to Tokyo on Wednesday to check on Senga.

“He is a healthy player who´s progressing through his offseason,” Stearns said. “He has not begun to throw yet, but that´s not necessarily abnormal for Senga as he goes through his offseason. We still expect him to be a pitcher for us on opening day and be ready to go.”

Stearns said Senga’s mechanics, which were off during the playoffs, will be monitored.

“We have to get not only the medical piece checked off, which I think we will be able to, but we also have to have a pitcher who feels really confident where he is from a mechanical perspective to compete and win games for us,” Stearns said. “It accentuates the need for depth, and that´s something that we talk about a lot and the desire to ensure that we have eight to 10 starting pitchers somewhere in our organization that we feel really confident about.”

Stearns is planning a six-man rotation for most of the season but one that drops to five when there are two days off in a week.

Stearns says there is no set payroll budget under owner Steve Cohen. The Mets have a pending record contract with All-Star outfielder Juan Soto that will be worth $765 million over 15 seasons.

“Steve and I talk about investments as they come and players as they become available in different opportunities and we´re evaluating each individual decision,” Stearns said. “As we have discussions, we´re constantly talking through the benefits and drawbacks of every decision. We´ve run very high payrolls. I think we´re going to continue to run high payrolls, but it´s not limitless and I understand that. So even if there´s not a firm, `this is the ceiling,’ I have to be disciplined because it´s not limitless and you have to leave yourself room to constantly improve the team.”

Stearns laughed when asked whether Grimace, the kid-friendly McDonald´s character, was part of the Mets’ video pitch to Japanese pitcher Roki Sasaki. Grimace became a good-luck charm after he threw out a ceremonial first pitch at Citi Field and New York went on a seven-game winning streak.

“I don’t believe that Grimace made – I can’t believe I’m answering this – I don’t believe that Grimace made an appearance in the Roki Sasaki presentation,” Stearns said. “If we don´t get the player, we now know why.”

New York sold its Triple-A Syracuse and Class A Brooklyn farm teams to Diamond Baseball Holdings, which bought Double-A Binghamton in April. The purchases increased Diamond’s total to 38 minor league teams. Stearns said the change in owners will not impact baseball operations.

New York Mets manager Carlos Mendoza smiles as he speaks to media at the Major League Baseball winter meetings, Monday, Dec. 9, 2024, in Dallas. (AP Photo/LM Otero)

Related Posts

🚨EXCLUSIVE: Everything you need to know about the Chicago White Sox’s 2026 Opening Day—key starters, roster updates, and what fans can expect from this revamped squad. Will they rise to the occasion, or is another disappointing season looming? The hype is real as the new season approaches…

What to know about Chicago White Sox Opening Day 2026: Starters, roster & more   undefined Looks like we’re having trouble loading this video. You can check…

🚨REPORT: Braves are predicted to make a blockbuster trade for Yankees’ Anthony Volpe, aiming to bolster their positional depth. Will this move make them unstoppable, or is it a risky gamble that could backfire? Fans are eagerly awaiting what could be a game-changer…

Getty Anthony Volpe #11 of the New York Yankees celebrates after he drove in the game winning run with a sacrifice fly in the 10th inning against…

🚨EXCLUSIVE: Red Sox receive crucial injury updates on Triston Casas and Romy Gonzalez just days before Opening Day—will they be ready to make an impact or is the season already in jeopardy? Fans are on edge as the countdown to the first pitch begins…

Getty TORONTO, CANADA – SEPTEMBER 24: Romy Gonzalez #23 of the Boston Red Sox hits an two-RBI single against the Toronto Blue Jays during the first inning…

🚨REPORT: Ranger Suárez ambushed in his final tune-up, leaving the Red Sox reeling and questioning their chances for the upcoming season. What went wrong in this last test, and can the team recover before the big games? Fans are anxious as the clock ticks down…

Red Sox News & Links: Ranger Suárez Struggles in Final Spring Training Start FORT MYERS, FLORIDA – As the Boston Red Sox wrap up their spring training…

🚨🔥 Alex Bregman Reveals Why He Chose the Chicago Cubs 👀👇 Bregman’s decision to sign with the Cubs is about more than just the game. What’s the real reason behind his move to Wrigleyville? Fans are eager to find out!

Alex Bregman is making it no secret — he wants to win as many World Series titles as possible. The veteran third baseman is entering his 10th…

🚨🔥 Yankees Make Another Major Roster Decision With Oswaldo Cabrera 👀👇 The Yankees have just made a significant move with Oswaldo Cabrera, and fans are wondering what it means for his future with the team. Big changes ahead — stay tuned!

Oswaldo Cabrera and Randal Grichuk have two different player profiles. Nevertheless, they were both competing for the final spot on the New York Yankees roster. Cabrera is…