Cubs Face a Nightmare in the Outfield: Matt Shaw’s Defensive Disasters Could Turn Wrigley into a Disaster Zone This Season

Chicago Cubs player Matt Shaw
Chicago Cubs player Matt Shaw | Allan Henry-Imagn Images

The Chicago Cubs are just a week away from Opening Day, and while there are a ton of questions surrounding the team, none are more pressing than what they are going to do in the outfield.

While the plan after losing Kyle Tucker was a return to right field for Seiya Suzuki, his status for Opening Day is now in question after a knee injury he sustained in the World Baseball Classic for Team Japan.

The backup plan, according to Craig Counsell, is young second-year player Matt Shaw, who steps into a utility role after losing his job at third base, which includes serving as the fourth outfielder despite little professional experience out there.

Shaw has had a very strong spring offensively, but after two errors on Wednesday, he now has three in just 33 outfield innings this spring. Of course, there are going to be growing pains, but Chicago cannot afford for the 24-year-old to be a complete defensive liability.

Cubs need at least decent right field defense

Chicago Cubs third baseman Matt Shaw tries to catch fly ball in outfielChicago Cubs third baseman Matt Shaw | Rick Scuteri-Imagn Images

Of course, asking Shaw to step into a position he hasn’t played since college will lead to a learning curve, but three errors in just 33 innings is a concern for a team that prides itself on defense and wins games because of it.

It does not sound like the Suzuki injury is going to be extremely serious, and should cost him less than a month of the season, but Chicago needs to weigh if it’s worth allowing Shaw to take the role, all things considered.

Giving Shaw that experience in the outfield could pay off down the line, assuming he improves, but it will be up to Craig Counsell to determine if he’s close enough to be able to learn on the job rather than just taking reps in practice.

Other directions Cubs could go in right field

Chicago Cubs outfielder Kevin Alcantara | Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images

Chicago does have other options if Shaw proves not to be ready, including top prospect Kevin Alcantara, who has just not taken that next step despite being expected to contribute the last couple of years.

Other minor league options include Chas McCormick, Dylan Carlson, or even Michael Conforto, all of whom obviously have big league playing experience but would be an offensive downgrade to Shaw.

How Counsell navigates this situation — and how long Suzuki is out for — could go a long way towards shaping what the first month of the season looks like for this team both offensively and defensively.

Related Posts

🔥 TRADE APOCALYPSE ALERT: Braves Eyeing $340M Elite 2x Gold Glove, 2x Silver Slugger by Trading Away Mike Yastrzemski! From luxury pickup to trade bait in months—is this the bold Anthopoulos masterstroke or a heartbreaking sell-high flop? Division just trembled! 👇👇👇

Atlanta Braves Predicted to Trade Mike Yastrzemski for Fernando Tatis Jr. in Bold Move The Atlanta Braves are expected to make a significant move this offseason, with…

⚾ WALKING RED FLAG ALERT: Red Sox’s $130M Ace Ranger Suárez Already Showing Cracks Before Opening Day! Nerves in debut, workload questions, early struggles—genius signing or massive regret incoming? Fans on edge! 👇👇👇

Ranger Suárez’s Five‑Year, $130 Million Deal — Big Expectations, Big Question Marks The Boston Red Sox signed left‑hander Ranger Suárez to a five‑year, $130 million contract this offseason —…

⚾ HEARTBREAK UPDATE: Red Sox’s Triston Casas Out Indefinitely—Opening Day Nightmare Continues! Knee rehab hits major roadblock, no Grapefruit League games, May return at earliest—will Boston’s power void doom the season? Fans devastated! 👇👇👇

Boston Red Sox Settle First Base Situation: Triston Casas’ Return Still Uncertain As the Boston Red Sox prepare for the 2026 season, a key question surrounding the…

⚾ RUSTY BUT ALIVE: Cole’s Raw Confession After Tommy John Comeback Pitch—”A Little Rusty… But Velocity Creeped Up!” Heart-pounding step forward or red flag? Your ace is back… sort of! 👇👇

Gerrit Cole Makes First Outing Since Tommy John Surgery: A Positive Step in His Recovery It was an exciting day for Gerrit Cole and the New York…

⚾ MAJOR CRISIS ALERT: Cubs Staring Down Disaster in the Outfield as Matt Shaw’s Defense Crumbles! Glove issues mounting fast—could this sink the young star’s future and force Chicago into desperate trades? Fans panicking! 👇👇👇

Chicago Cubs Face Outfield Dilemma as Matt Shaw Struggles Defensively As Opening Day approaches, the Chicago Cubs find themselves grappling with a significant outfield issue that could…

🔥 TERROR ALERT ACTIVATED: $ Big Move $ Chiefs Pair Chris Jones With 8-Time Pro Bowl Edge Terror! Sack records incoming, division rivals panicking— this defensive nightmare is real and it’s here! 👇👇👇

Kansas City, MO — March 19, 2026 The Kansas City Chiefs have made it clear this offseason that standing still is not an option. After missing the…