The Dallas Cowboys are at a crossroads when it comes to George Pickens. Trading him might seem like a step back, but with the right offer, it could be a strategic move. The recent blockbuster trade involving Jaylen Waddle gives us a glimpse into what’s possible.
The Denver Broncos just made waves by acquiring Miami Dolphins’ wideout Jaylen Waddle. In exchange, they gave up a hefty package: a first-round pick, a third-round pick, and a fourth-round pick, while receiving Waddle and a fourth-rounder from Miami. This trade sets a high bar for wide receiver value, and it’s worth considering what Dallas could fetch for Pickens.
Waddle, a former No. 6 overall pick, has been a solid contributor with an average of 81 catches for 1,098 yards and six touchdowns over six seasons. But even with those numbers, few expected him to command such a high price. His production has dipped recently, averaging 890 receiving yards over the past three years, and despite Tyreek Hill’s absence last season, Waddle didn’t break the 1,000-yard mark.
Enter George Pickens, who has been nothing short of spectacular. With CeeDee Lamb sidelined due to injury, Pickens stepped up, ranking among the league’s best with 93 catches, 1,429 yards, and a passer rating of 120.1 when targeted. His explosiveness and ability as a downfield threat make him a standout.
Comparing Pickens to Waddle isn’t straightforward. While Waddle resembles more of a CeeDee Lamb-type receiver, Pickens brings a unique skill set.
The real question is, how many receivers are truly better than Pickens right now? That list is short.
Pickens’ value has undoubtedly increased since last offseason when he was available for a third-rounder. The catch? He’s not under contract, and any team looking to acquire him would need to offer a hefty salary, possibly over $30 million annually, along with draft picks.
The Waddle trade gives the Cowboys significant leverage. They can argue that a younger, less productive player like Waddle was worth a first, third, and a pick swap. While Pickens does carry some maturity concerns, his trajectory is on the rise at just 25 years old, unlike Waddle, who might have peaked at 28.
This is a pivotal moment for the Cowboys’ front office. The decision to trade Pickens could reshape the team’s future, and it’s a conversation that should be happening behind closed doors right now.
