St. Louis Cardinals Catching Conundrum: A Spring Training Puzzle

Spring training often serves as a stage for experimentation, but every now and then, it offers glimpses into the future roster. In Jupiter, Florida, the St. Louis Cardinals are facing an intriguing challenge behind the plate, and Yohel Pozo’s unexpected role might just be the key to unlocking it.

With three catchers expected on the opening day roster, the Cardinals have some decisions to make. Pedro Pagés, the steady presence, is likely to continue his role as the primary catcher.

Meanwhile, Iván Herrera, recovering from elbow surgery, is still working his way back to full strength. If Herrera’s bat is ready, he’ll find his way into the lineup.

The real battle is between Pozo and Jimmy Crooks for the final catching spot. Crooks, a young talent, presents an opportunity for the Cardinals to invest in their future.

However, with a roster already heavy with left-handed bats, finding room for Crooks can be tricky. If he doesn’t make the big-league cut, Memphis might be his next stop, but a strict timeshare there could hinder both his and Leo Bernal’s development.

Manager Oli Marmol has highlighted the progress Crooks has made, both offensively and in terms of communication with the pitching staff. His lefty bat is traditionally a roster asset, but the Cardinals’ current lineup dynamics complicate matters.

Enter Pozo, who recently took ground balls at first base. Until the Cardinals signed Ramón Urías, Pozo was the closest thing to a backup right-handed first baseman, supporting Alec Burleson. While Urías adds depth, Pozo’s leadership and clubhouse presence remain invaluable, as evidenced by his Darryl Kile Award.

Crooks, on the other hand, is praised for his energy and game-planning skills. Despite a tough stint at the plate last season, his potential is undeniable. It’s clear he’s close to breaking through, but the path isn’t straightforward.

Marmol acknowledges the complexity of the situation, especially with the possibility of a logjam at Memphis. When asked about the potential for both Bernal and Crooks to grow if they don’t make the majors, Marmol’s response was telling: “Is there a way for both of them to take strides forward if they don’t make the big leagues? What if I said no?”

The Cardinals are in an enviable position with a wealth of catching talent, but it means tough choices lie ahead. Whether these players shift positions or even teams, the situation underscores the competitive nature of roster building.

As spring training unfolds, the Cardinals are not just trying to fill a roster; they’re shaping their future. The answers might not be clear today, but the journey to find them is what makes baseball so compelling.