Brandon Aubrey Contract Rumors: Will the Dallas Cowboys Re-Sign Their Pro Bowl Star?

Dallas Cowboys Pro Bowl kicker Brandon Aubrey is quickly becoming one of the most fascinating names to watch as NFL free agency approaches. In a league where elite kickers rarely generate headline-level bidding wars, Aubrey is proving to be the exception.

Amid swirling NFL rumors, Aubrey addressed his uncertain contract status during Super Bowl week — and his comments suggest he hopes his future remains firmly planted in Dallas.

Brandon Aubrey Speaks on His Future in Dallas

Despite the contract speculation, Aubrey’s tone has been steady and optimistic about staying with the Cowboys long term.

“We’ve got to make some improvement,” Aubrey said during Super Bowl week. “Find a way to win more football games so we’re in the playoffs and hopefully next year we’re in the game (Super Bowl) that we’re about to go watch.”

His remarks reflect a player focused not only on personal milestones but on team progress. Aubrey also praised new head coach Brian Schottenheimer, pointing to a cultural shift within the organization.

“I think Schotty has brought a big culture change,” Aubrey explained. “He’s more fun-loving and bringing the love of the game back to players, because once you get to the professional ranks, it’s hard. You see it’s a business. It’s hard to keep having fun playing the game.”

When asked directly about his future with the Cowboys, Aubrey didn’t hesitate: “Love to be in Dallas.”

However, desire and dollars do not always align in NFL negotiations.

Cowboys Rumors: Aubrey Seeking $10 Million Per Year

Since those comments, contract discussions have reportedly hit a financial hurdle.

According to ESPN’s Todd Archer, both the Cowboys and Aubrey’s representation agree that he deserves to become the highest-paid kicker in the NFL. The debate centers on how much higher than the current market ceiling that number should be.

At present, the benchmark belongs to Harrison Butker of the Kansas City Chiefs, who earns an average annual salary of $6.4 million.

Dallas has reportedly offered Aubrey a deal that surpasses Butker’s average. However, Aubrey’s agent, Todd France, is said to be seeking a contract closer to $10 million per season.

That figure would dramatically reset the kicker market.

Why Brandon Aubrey Has Leverage as a Restricted Free Agent

Aubrey enters the offseason as a restricted free agent (RFA). This designation gives Dallas significant control. The Cowboys have the right to match any offer sheet another team presents.

That leverage could slow negotiations.

Rather than bidding against themselves, the Cowboys can wait to see whether another franchise is willing to meet Aubrey’s asking price. If a competitive offer materializes, Dallas can then decide whether to match it or accept draft compensation, depending on the tender level applied.

However, elite kickers rarely hit the open market — and Aubrey is no ordinary specialist.

Brandon Aubrey’s Market Value Projection

According to contract projections from Spotrac, Aubrey’s estimated market value sits around four years, $26.1 million — an average of roughly $6.5 million per year.

That valuation aligns more closely with Butker’s current deal than the $10 million annual salary Aubrey is reportedly targeting.

So why the gap?

The difference likely reflects:

• Aubrey’s Pro Bowl status

• His rare long-range consistency

• The rising importance of elite special teams in close NFL games

• Inflation within premium specialist contracts

The Cowboys must now decide whether Aubrey is worth redefining the financial ceiling for kickers.

Elite Range Makes Aubrey Unique

What truly separates Aubrey from many of his peers is his leg strength.

His longest made field goal in an NFL regular-season game stands at 65 yards — an elite mark that immediately places him among the strongest-legged kickers in league history.

Yet Aubrey believes he can push even further.

“I think it’s not out of the realm of possibility to go to 72, 73 (yards),” Aubrey said. “That’s probably about the max for me. I wouldn’t say that’s the max for anyone in the league. Guys are getting better and better.”

A successful 70-plus-yard field goal would shatter traditional expectations and redefine strategic range across the league. Even the threat of that distance changes end-of-half play-calling, clock management, and fourth-down decision-making.

In today’s NFL, where parity leads to razor-thin margins, that kind of weapon carries measurable value.

Cowboys Salary Cap Strategy: Pay a Kicker $10 Million?

The central question facing Dallas is philosophical as much as financial.

Do you allocate $10 million annually to a kicker, even one as elite as Aubrey?

Kickers traditionally occupy a smaller percentage of team cap space. However, games are increasingly decided by narrow margins, and postseason matchups often hinge on special teams execution.

For a franchise like Dallas — consistently competitive but seeking a deeper playoff breakthrough — stability at kicker is not trivial.

If the Cowboys believe Aubrey provides a weekly advantage, paying a premium could be justified. If they view him as replaceable within a strong special teams system, negotiations could stall.

Potential Free Agency Bidding War?

While kickers rarely trigger major bidding wars, Aubrey’s profile makes him an outlier.

Teams with:

• Strong rosters but inconsistent kicking

• Indoor stadiums that amplify long-range value

• Cap flexibility and playoff aspirations

could see Aubrey as a finishing piece rather than a luxury.

That dynamic puts subtle pressure on Dallas. Waiting too long could embolden aggressive front offices willing to test the RFA process.

Culture Shift Under Brian Schottenheimer

Aubrey’s praise for Brian Schottenheimer adds another dimension to this situation.

If players are responding positively to the cultural changes, retaining key contributors becomes even more important. Allowing a respected Pro Bowler to depart over a financial standoff could send unintended signals within the locker room.

On the other hand, disciplined cap management is part of long-term roster sustainability.

Balancing those competing priorities will define this negotiation.

Final Outlook: Will Brandon Aubrey Stay in Dallas?

All signs suggest Aubrey wants to remain with the Cowboys. The team holds contractual leverage as a restricted free agent, but the price tag remains the sticking point.

Key factors to monitor:

• Whether another team submits a formal offer sheet

• Dallas’ willingness to exceed the $6.4 million annual benchmark

• How much the Cowboys prioritize resetting the kicker market

If Dallas meets Aubrey closer to his reported $10 million request, he could become the highest-paid kicker in NFL history. If not, the Cowboys may gamble on market resistance.

One thing is clear: Brandon Aubrey is no ordinary free agent kicker. His leg strength, consistency, and postseason ambitions make him a rare commodity — and the Cowboys must now decide just how rare they believe he truly is.