The Pittsburgh Steelers have been on the hunt for a reliable wide receiver for quite some time. Their recent acquisition of DK Metcalf during the 2025 offseason seemed promising, but it also meant parting ways with George Pickens, leaving them with a familiar void to fill.

Enter Tyreek Hill, who recently became a free agent after being released by the Miami Dolphins. Hill, a superstar receiver with eight consecutive Pro Bowl selections and five First-Team All-Pro honors since 2016, has been a force on the field. His back-to-back seasons with over 1,700 receiving yards in 2022 and 2023 are a testament to his elite playmaking ability.

However, despite the Steelers’ need for a wideout, pursuing Hill may not be the wisest move. Here’s why.

First, Hill is recovering from a severe knee injury that ended his 2025 season after just four games. This wasn’t your typical ACL tear; it involved a dislocated knee and multiple torn ligaments.

Five months into his recovery, there’s talk of another surgery, and concerns about potential nerve damage loom large. With his availability for the 2026 season uncertain and his 32nd birthday approaching, it’s fair to question whether Hill can return to his former explosive self.

But the injury isn’t the only concern. Hill is also embroiled in a domestic violence investigation stemming from allegations in September 2025, following a civil suit in 2024. His past legal issues, including a guilty plea for domestic assault in 2014, further complicate his situation.

Even if Hill’s health were impeccable, these off-field issues present significant risks. The Steelers, looking to build a strong and positive team culture, would likely want to avoid the potential PR fallout from signing a player with such a controversial background.

Ultimately, while the Steelers need a strong partner for DK Metcalf, Tyreek Hill doesn’t seem to be the right fit. The team must prioritize finding a receiver who not only brings talent but also aligns with their values and long-term vision.