MLB INSIDER: Proposes interesting New York Mets trade for versatile 2-time All-Star to replace Pete Alonso

An MLB insider proposed an interesting trade proposal for the New York Mets that lands them a potential replacement for Pete Alonso.

The Mets are currently one of the few teams with a legitimate shot at signing superstar outfielder Juan Soto this offseason. It is currently their top priority as they look to bolster a team that reached the National League Championship Series in October.

Related: MLB insider proposes bold New York Mets trade for 3-time All-Star pitcher

However, the organization has three of its starters available on the open market and homegrown All-Star slugger Pete Alonso. Whether they land Soto, there is a very real chance they lose their starting first baseman in MLB free agency this offseason.

It is why on Wednesday, ESPN MLB insider David Schoenfield suggested a bold trade for a former NL MVP that could replace Alonso, or possibly even center fielder Brandon Nimmo in 2025.

Could the New York Mets target a trade for 2-time All-Star Cody Bellinger?

MLB insider proposes interesting New York Mets trade for versatile 2-time All-Star to replace Pete Alonso
Credit: Kyle Ross-Imagn Images

“If the Mets don’t sign Soto, they’ll have tons of room to use on their payroll,” Schoenfield wrote. “Some of that will be needed to reload the rotation, but adding [Cody] Bellinger as a full-time center fielder fills a need while allowing them to keep Brandon Nimmo in left and Tyrone Taylor as a fourth outfielder. Or, if the Mets don’t sign Pete Alonso, Bellinger could play first base.”

The 29-year-old has a strong season in 2023 that was probably worth a third trip to the All-Star game. However, the Los Angeles Dodgers and Chicago Cubs veteran had an off season last year. It is part of why he did not opt out of his contract this year. And is on the trade block instead of in free agency.

His versatility would be a good addition for the New York Mets and offer them some strong fallback options if they fail in their Juan Soto pursuit and don’t re-sign Pete Alonso.

Related Posts

🚨 MLB DRAMA: Frank Thomas Responds After White Sox’s Shocking Black History Month Post Snub — Is This the Beginning of a Bigger Rift? The Iconic Hall of Famer Is Not Holding Back! 👇

Frank Thomas Hits Back at White Sox After Glaring Black History Month Post Snub By Yasmin Edañol February 2, 2026 at 9:28 AM ET Chicago — Frank…

🚨 NETFLIX DROPS TRAILER FOR “MOOKIE BETTS: THE MIND THAT REDEFINED BASKETBALL” — A DOCUMENTARY THAT’S SHAKING THE SPORTS WORLD 🚨 In an unexpected twist, Netflix’s new documentary on Mookie Betts is already being hailed as one of the most intellectually powerful and emotionally grounded portraits of an athlete ever. Don’t miss the premiere!

Netflix Unveils “Mookie Betts: The Mind That Redefined Basketball,” a Documentary Already Rewriting How Greatness Is Understood When Netflix quietly released the official trailer for “Mookie Betts:…

🚨 BREAKING: BOSTON RED SOX RELEASE TWO ROOKIES FOR UNPROFESSIONAL CONDUCT AND LACK OF TEAM CULTURE FIT 🚨 In а ѕhockіng move, the Boѕton Red Sox hаve releаѕed two rookіeѕ over unрrofeѕѕіonаl behаvіor аnd fаіlure to аlіgn wіth the teаm’ѕ culture. Whаt doeѕ thіѕ meаn for the future of the teаm?

BOѕTON — іn а ѕurрrіѕe eаrly‑offѕeаѕon move thаt’ѕ mаkіng heаdlіneѕ throughout Mаjor Leаgue Bаѕebаll, the Boѕton Red ѕox hаve аnnounced the releаѕe of two rookіe рlаyerѕ thіѕ week for…

🚨 BRAVES FANS SHOCKED: Atlanta Set to Remove $30M All-Star from Rotation and Sign Lucas Giolito — What Does This Bold Move Mean for the Team’s Future? Is Giolito the Missing Piece to Push Them to the Next Level? Fans Are Stunned! 👇

Braves Predicted to Remove $30M All-Star from Rotation, Sign Lucas Giolito Published: February 02, 2026 at 12:33 PM ESTBy Aaliyan Mohammed, Contributing Sports Writer As the Atlanta…

🚨 SPRING TRAINING IS COMING: Red Sox Equipment Truck Makes a Stop at Polar Park on the Way to Florida — What Does This Mean for the Team’s 2026 Spring Plans? Fans Are Buzzing with Excitement! 👇

‘Spring is on the Way’: Red Sox Equipment Truck Stops by Polar Park En Route to FloridaStory by Worcester Telegram & Gazette Baseball season is finally on…

🚨 RED SOX FANS, PAY ATTENTION: Jarren Duran Is Getting Major Buzz Amid Trade Rumors — Could This Be the Moment He Breaks Out? With Bold Projections on the Horizon, What’s Next for the Young Star? The Talk Is Heating Up! 👇

Red Sox’s Jarren Duran Gets Bullish Projection Amid Trade RumorsBy Jackson Roberts As the Boston Red Sox continue to prepare for their 2026 season, one name that…