
Considering that it required another part of the Rafael Devers trade tree that appears dead in the water at this point, it’s fair to feel like the Boston Red Sox still have yet to properly address the way they’ve mismanaged the hot corner situation over the last 12 months.
But make no mistake about it: Caleb Durbin is the real deal. The trade with the Milwaukee Brewers — which also netted the Sox Andruw Monasterio, Anthony Seigler, and a top-75 draft pick — was a brilliant feat of roster maneuvering by the front office, moving off a few superfluous pieces in exchange for tons of team control and versatility.
Durbin, a former New York Yankees prospect, is the obvious centerpiece after finishing third in National League Rookie of the Year voting in 2025. He earned that distinction after hitting .256/.334/.387 (105 wRC+) with 11 homers and 18 steals, emerging as the Crew’s starting third baseman.
Now expected to slide over to second base as Marcelo Mayer takes the reins at third, can the soon-to-be 26-year-old finally resolve the keystone carousel that has plagued the Red Sox for years?
Caleb Durbin is a regression candidate at the plate, but he still brings a high floor to Red Sox
Those that take a quick glance at Durbin’s Baseball Savant page will notice that, outside of his superlative contact numbers, he’s not a particularly advanced hitter. He doesn’t work a ton of walks, swings a slow bat, and rarely hits the ball hard. Perhaps, fearing some impending regression, the Brewers sold high on him.
And while those pitfalls are real, it’s also true that Durbin almost never strikes out or whiffs, adding some much-needed bat-to-ball skills to the lineup. Though he doesn’t possess the kind of power fans have been hoping for since Alex Bregman left in free agency, he did pull the ball in the air more than 20% of the time last year, a hugely important skill for a right-handed batter in Fenway Park. He should have no problem clanging numerous extra-base hits off and over the Green Monster in 2026 and beyond.
“Beyond” is a key term there, seeing as Durbin is team-controlled through 2031. As great as all of the team’s additions have been this offseason, each is either expensive, short-term, or both. The versatile infielder should be an affordable asset for the next six seasons.
Plus, even if his bat never develops further than what he showed last year, a contact hitter with exemplary speed and strong defensive instincts across the infield is still a valuable starter. He’s already a huge improvement over David Hamilton (who was also sent to Milwaukee in the deal) and gives the team a viable backup plan if Mayer falters or Trevor Story goes down with another injury.
As it stands, this trade already appears to be a massive win for the Red Sox. If Durbin takes another step forward in Boston, though, this could be the kind of move that pries a contention window open for a long time.