The Soto Score: How signing MLB’s No. 1 free agent would shift his suitors’ fortunes

The Soto Score: How signing MLB's No. 1 free agent would shift his suitors' fortunes

EXCLUSIVE CONTENT

Get ESPN+

The Soto Score: How signing MLB's No. 1 free agent would shift his suitors' fortunes
Juan Soto would make any team better (including Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s Blue Jays). But exactly how much better varies. We put a number on it. Jim McIsaac/Getty Images
  • The Soto Score: How signing MLB's No. 1 free agent would shift his suitors' fortunes

    Bradford Doolittle, ESPN Staff WriterDec 4, 2024, 07:00 AM ET

    Close

    • Sports reporter, Kansas City Star, 2002-09
    • Writer, Baseball, Baseball Prospectus
    • Co-author, Pro Basketball Prospectus
    • Member, Baseball Writers Association of America
    • Member, Professional Basketball Writers Association

The Juan Soto chase appears to be nearing a conclusion. As the offseason’s biggest domino wobbles, it’s a good time to illustrate what’s at stake when it falls.

From a pure baseball standpoint, Soto’s pending decision should capture the interest of all 30 teams. News flash: Soto is really good. He’s also still only 26 and the team that lands him should get to watch him continue to build on a first-ballot Hall of Fame career for the next decade or more.

That makes one interpretation of his impact blatantly obvious: If you sign Soto, he makes you better. If you don’t, you aren’t going to be as good as you would have been if you did.

We know Soto will make any team that signs him better by around five wins, all things being equal. That number varies somewhat, but that’s a good thumbnail number — the difference between Soto and whatever player his acquisition would push down the depth chart.

Not every team can afford to pursue him though, and the competitive context for each team that can is different. This is what we want to focus on today — competitive context. Those five wins matter more, and in different ways, depending on which suitor we’re talking about.

So let’s talk about some of those suitors. The rumor mill has given us five leading possibilities — teams believed to have already forwarded offers to Soto and superagent Scott Boras. Those are the Yankees, Mets, Dodgers, Red Sox and Blue Jays.

To that quintet, we’ll add three teams:

• The Phillies, just because you never know when Dave Dombrowski will swoop in.

• The Giants, because they typify teams that should arguably be more aggressive in the Soto market (and others) but haven’t shown much indication that is going to happen.

• The Royals, who were briefly attached to Soto very early in the process for, reportedly, making a call about him. But the Royals typify the kind of midlevel team in a not-large market that might get an outsized gain from a splash like this. It won’t happen, but it’s illustrative to see how much of an impact a player of Soto’s value could have on clubs.

Related Posts

🚨 MLB INSIDE RESET: The White Sox’s newly assembled coaching staff is raising quiet but serious questions across the league, as subtle hires, shifted responsibilities, and a clear change in philosophy hint at a deeper organizational reset. What looks like routine restructuring on the surface may actually signal a long term plan that hasn’t been fully explained yet — and insiders believe the real impact will only become clear once the season pressure hits.

The Chicago White Sox have finalized their coaching staff for the 2026 season following sweeping changes made at the end of September.

🚨 MLB INSIDE TRADE RUMBLINGS: The Braves are suddenly being linked to a bold trade for a $6 million NL rival left hander, a move insiders say could quietly solve multiple problems at once and even position him as a long term heir to Chris Sale. What looks like a low risk deal on paper may actually hide a far bigger plan, with Atlanta reportedly intrigued by a dynamic arsenal that hasn’t fully been unlocked yet — and the timing of this rumor is raising serious eyebrows across the league.

The Braves could go after a young star.

🚨 MLB INSIDE STORM BREWING: As hopes of an Alex Bregman return quietly fade, a new projection suggests the Red Sox may be preparing a jaw dropping $186 million swing for Bo Bichette, a move insiders believe could redefine Boston’s future in one bold stroke. What once seemed unrealistic is now gaining traction behind the scenes, and if this prediction turns real, the ripple effect could shock the AL East and completely change how this offseason is remembered.

A former MLB executive now believes that the Boston Red Sox will land coveted free agent infielder Bo Bichette from Toronto.

🚨 MLB INSIDE WHISPERS: Something big is quietly brewing behind closed doors in New York, as new projections hint the Yankees may be lining up an elite shortstop signing that goes far beyond a normal free-agency move. What started as a low-key prediction is now being viewed as a potential power shift, with insiders suggesting this decision could redefine the Yankees’ identity and force the entire American League to adjust sooner than expected.

The New York Yankees haven’t done much during the offseason, but MLB rumors continue to swirl. New York has been […]

Cubs Predicted To Land Marquee Free Agent Starting Pitcher On Six-Year Contract

The Cubs are in the market for a top-of-the-rotation starting pitcher, and David Schoenfield of ESPN predicted them to land Framber Valdez, previously of the Houston Astros.

🚨 INSIDE NFL REVELATION: The Packers reportedly had a stunning opportunity to sign an all time great for just $5 million, yet chose to walk away without even making a free agent offer — a quiet decision that is now raising serious questions inside the fanbase and league circles alike. What seemed insignificant at the time is suddenly being revisited as a potential turning point, with insiders suggesting this missed move could have changed far more than anyone realized.

Green Bay missed an opportunity.