
Hereās what Iāve learned over the past week:
⢠I need to give Aaron Rodgers another chance to be the Pittsburgh Steelersā quarterback.
⢠I also need to give Will Howard a chance to be the Steelersā quarterback.
⢠Iām being too hard on the Mike McCarthy hire.
⢠Iām not being hard enough on Mike Tomlin going out the door.
Aside from that, everything Iāve written over the past week has been spot on.
I appreciate your feedback, as well as your concern about the Pirates, Pitt basketball and my college alma mater.
You are all very kind and caring people. Letās see proof of that in this weekās āU mad, bro?ā
This guyĀ disagreed with my assessmentĀ that Aaron Rodgers shouldnāt be Pittsburghās starting quarterback next year.
āIām not in favor of bringing Aaron back, but who do you suggest that is better thatās available?ā
Somebody else.
Somebody who isnāt 43 years old and didnāt just go 1-5 against playoff teams last year.
Hereās a message from Stan.
How do you count Juan Thornhill? As a never-was or a has-been?
Or both?
Howard is āTeam Howardā ⦠Will Howard. Go figure.
āDo you think the Patriots thought Brady was their future when they drafted him in that 6th round? Weāll never know about Howard unless and until THEY PLAY HIM!ā
Howard, did you think Omar Jacobs, Landry Jones or Mason Rudolph were the future? Or do you just think that of Howard because itās necessary to believe that now since there is no clear starter as opposed to those guys who were drafted behind Ben Roethlisberger?
By the way, all those guys were drafted earlier than Howard was.
Will Howard-mania is based around his college resume, a matter of convenience with no obvious franchise QB in front of him and the sixth-round-Brady coincidence.
Itās not because of his draft stock or anything that youāve seen of him as a pro, because no one has seen anything of him as a pro.
If Howard proves to be worth anything as a player, itāll be because he has to be played. Brady played because of an injury to Drew Bledsoe. Howard may have to play because there is no better choice.
Iād prefer looking for a better choice before they have to go to Howard. If one canāt be found, so be it. Itās cross our fingers hope for the best at that point, I guess.
But letās avoid pretending that having Howard start Game 1 of 2026 would be for any other reason besides that.
Jake wants me to fanboy out for new Steelersā head coach Mike McCarthy.
āWhy so negative against Mike McCarthy? You and practically every other local sports commentator seem to have decided that choosing McCarthy as the Steelersā new coach is the same as keeping Tomlin⦠Cāmon, manā¦Stop with the negativityā¦give the guy a chance.
āBesides, he canāt possibly be as bad as Tomlin, who was a bigger failure than most people will admitā¦by that I mean he not only failed to develop a QB, he set the franchise back at least 5 years by choosing guys like Pickett, Trubisky, Wilson, Fieldsā¦and Mason Rudolph. Tomlin also failed to develop other positionsā¦he wasted myriad first-round picks on the OL, which is still merely mediocre at best. And he kept a declining TJ Watt, and wasted a ton of money on him.ā
So, you donāt want me to say that McCarthy is basically the same guy as Tomlin (even though,Ā as I pointed out, he had one playoff win in his last seven seasons, as Tomlin failed to win one in his last nine).
Yet, for McCarthy to be better than Tomlin, he needs to be better than 10-7, win the AFC North and win a playoff game. He will have to do so with a 43-year-old Rodgers coming back, Rudolph or Howard.
You understand what youāre saying, right?
You donāt want me to point that out because he speaks with a familiar accent, nāat? Would you be so pro-McCarthy if he were from anywhere else but Pittsburgh?
Youāre trying to inflate your expectations of what McCarthy can be by tearing down Tomlin. Your complaints about Tomlin may be valid. But complaints about Tomlin donāt make McCarthy better.
Itās not my job to āgive him a chance.ā Art Rooney II already did that. My job is to talk about why that was wise or unwise to do.
I think itās a conservative, safe, low-ceiling hire. Sorry if thatās the wrong thing to say in your mind because you prefer to see McCarthyās tires pumped.
But something tells me if he were from Greenwich, Conn., instead of Greenfield, youād be less put off by the opinion.
After their latest brutal loss to North Carolina on Monday night, Sports Illustratedās Pat Forde sent this post about my beleaguered Syracuse Orange basketball team.
When I reposted that, Robert replied.
Please, Robert. One crisis at a time, OK?
Finally, Rich V has an idea about how to help the Pirates.
āUPMC and PNC recently donated millions to Da āBurg for rescue/EMS vehicles and plow trucks, respectively. Seems like now would be a good time for ole Bob Wins-Nutting to go hat-in-hand looking for corporate donations in order buy some power hitters for the batting order! What do you think?ā
Iām assuming thatās how they already got Brandon Lowe and Ryan OāHearn. I prefer to get my street plowed before I worry about the Pirates getting a third baseman.