
The San Francisco Giants just made a move that’s as smart as it is strategic, signing Luis Arraez – a three-time batting champ and one of the purest contact hitters in the game. But this isn’t just about adding a high-average bat to the lineup. It’s about building in flexibility, depth, and a little insurance for one of the club’s most exciting young prospects: Bryce Eldridge.
Let’s break it down. Heading into spring training, Eldridge looked like the frontrunner to take over the designated hitter role, especially after his rapid rise through the minors last year. But now, with Arraez in the fold, the Giants have given themselves a safety net – and that’s a move that shows foresight.
Eldridge is just 21, and while his talent is undeniable, the track record is still being written. He started last season in Double-A, impressed with his power, but also racked up a lot of strikeouts.
Then came a quick jump to Triple-A Sacramento, and eventually a September call-up to the bigs. In that brief stint, he collected just three hits in 28 at-bats – a reminder that the leap to MLB pitching is no small thing.
So, what’s the smart play here? Let Eldridge get more seasoning in Triple-A to start the year.
Let him find his rhythm, build confidence, and force the Giants’ hand with his bat. There’s no need to rush a player with his upside, especially when you’ve got someone like Arraez who can hold things down in the meantime.
And it’s not just about DH. Arraez is slated to start the year at second base, but his glove has always lagged behind his bat.
If the defense becomes an issue – and it might – the Giants have the option to slide him into the DH role or even first base if needed. That kind of versatility is gold in a 162-game season.
There’s also the Jerar Encarnación factor. He’s out of minor league options, so the Giants may choose to give him a look at DH early in the season.
If it clicks, great. If not, they pivot.
With Arraez in the mix, they have the roster flexibility to make those kinds of adjustments on the fly.
Bottom line: Arraez isn’t just a high-contact, low-strikeout bat – though that in itself is a valuable commodity in today’s game – he’s a stabilizing piece. He gives the Giants options. And when you’re trying to balance development with contention, that’s exactly what you want.
Eldridge still has the tools to be a star. But with Arraez on board, the Giants don’t have to bet the house on him being ready from day one. Instead, they’ve given themselves room to breathe – and a better chance to get the most out of both players.