Carlos Mendoza Reflects on 2025 Mets’ Struggles: Lack of Chemistry and Celebration Led to Disappointment
The New York Mets have experienced a turbulent few years, where expectations were high, but results often fell short. Between 2021 and 2025, the team’s odd-numbered years were plagued by disappointment—not just in terms of wins and losses, but also in the undercurrents of dysfunction within the team. Now, as the Mets try to rebuild and regroup for the future, manager Carlos Mendoza is opening up about the deeper issues that may have caused the team’s downfall in 2025.
The Lack of Celebration: A Missing Ingredient in 2025
In his recent interview, Mendoza did not shy away from acknowledging a crucial factor that contributed to the Mets’ struggles: a lack of celebration and connection among the players.
In baseball, chemistry is more than just a buzzword; it’s an essential part of success. From the dugout to the locker room, the best teams share an energy and belief that transcends just playing the game—it’s about celebrating each other’s successes and building trust through those moments. Unfortunately for the Mets in 2025, that sense of camaraderie was missing.
Mendoza pointed out that the Mets didn’t make enough of an effort to celebrate each other’s achievements, big or small. In a grueling 162-game season, these small moments of joy and mutual recognition aren’t just nice—they’re vital. They build trust, they build belief, and when they’re absent, it’s easy for a team to become disjointed.
The 2024 Contrast: A Team with Identity
When reflecting on the 2024 season, despite the disappointing end, Mendoza noted that the Mets had an identity. The team had its own unique vibe, encapsulated by the now-infamous “OMG Mets” sign that became a symbol of their energy and fun. Jose Iglesias, who brought an infectious spirit to the locker room, was key to that identity. Even though the 2024 season ended on a down note, that sense of fun and energy was a defining factor.
However, that vibe didn’t carry over into 2025. Despite attempts from Starling Marte to bring life back into the dugout with the “Home Run Chancla” celebration, it never really took off in the same way. The team felt rudderless, searching for something to rally around but never quite finding it.
The Soto Factor: Talent Meets Reserved Leadership
One of the most significant changes for the Mets in 2025 was the addition of Juan Soto to the roster. While Soto’s presence undeniably boosted the team’s talent, his more reserved and businesslike approach to the game introduced a different dynamic in the clubhouse. Soto’s laser focus and commitment to results are attributes that make him one of the best in the game, but that doesn’t necessarily translate to the vocal leadership and high-energy presence that a team like the Mets may need in times of struggle.
Unlike players like Francisco Lindor, who is known for his exuberant personality and leadership in the locker room, Soto’s more stoic demeanor may have made the team feel colder at times. While not directly attributed to the team’s struggles, Mendoza acknowledged that the Mets may have overthought how to build relationships within the team. The lack of chemistry became more apparent as the season wore on.
Mendoza’s Accountability and the Road Ahead
To his credit, Carlos Mendoza didn’t shy away from addressing the issues. During Bo Bichette’s introductory press conference, Mendoza took full responsibility for the challenges the team faced in 2025. He emphasized the importance of communication and clearly defining roles for each player—two things that can drastically improve a team’s daily routine and cohesion.
What stood out was Mendoza’s personal commitment to changing the culture. He seemed genuinely invested in learning from the mistakes of the previous season and adapting as a manager. This self-awareness is a crucial first step in fixing what went wrong in 2025.
The Mets’ Opportunity for a New Beginning
With new faces like Bo Bichette joining the team and a renewed emphasis on rebuilding a cohesive, positive clubhouse culture, the Mets are poised to turn the page. The talent is undeniably there, but the question remains: Can the Mets rebuild their chemistry and camaraderie to match their on-field potential?
In baseball, as in life, you don’t just win with stats—you win with people. Mendoza and the Mets are learning this lesson the hard way, but with a fresh focus on communication, celebrating each other’s success, and fostering a team-first mentality, they might just be able to put the disappointment of 2025 behind them and build a more united, successful future in Queens.
This version highlights Carlos Mendoza’s candid assessment of the 2025 Mets’ struggles, focusing on the lack of team chemistry and celebration as key factors in their disappointing season. It emphasizes Mendoza’s self-awareness and determination to improve the team’s culture, while also discussing the impact of Juan Soto’s leadership style and the Mets’ future potential with new acquisitions like Bo Bichette.
