Brewers Include Tobias Myers in Freddy Peralta Trade to Mets as Pitcher’s Family Reacts

The Milwaukee Brewers made waves across Major League Baseball on Wednesday when they officially decided to move on from longtime right-hander Freddy Peralta, trading the ace to the New York Mets in a blockbuster deal.

However, Peralta was not the only pitcher heading to Queens.

Right-handed pitcher Tobias Myers was also included in the transaction, as Milwaukee received two prospects in return from New York. While Peralta dominated headlines, Myers’ departure quietly marked the end of an important chapter in his young MLB career.

Tobias Myers’ Rise with Milwaukee

Myers enjoyed a strong breakthrough season with the Brewers in 2024, emerging as a reliable arm in the starting rotation. Across 27 appearances — including 25 starts — the right-hander compiled a 9–6 record with a 3.00 ERA, 3.91 FIP, and 1.174 WHIP. He struck out 127 batters over 138 innings and posted an impressive 138 ERA+, signaling above-average performance at the major league level.

At times, Myers looked like a long-term rotation piece for Milwaukee. His ability to mix pitches effectively and limit hard contact allowed him to thrive despite not being considered a top-tier prospect earlier in his career.

A Challenging 2025 Season

Unfortunately, Myers was unable to maintain that same level of success in 2025.

Inconsistency and roster competition pushed him back to Triple-A for much of the season, limiting his opportunities with the Brewers’ big-league club. Still, when he was called upon late in the year, Myers showed flashes of the pitcher he had been the year before.

Over his final eight appearances of the regular season, Myers allowed just three earned runs on 11 hits, issuing only three walks and surrendering a single home run across 13.1 innings. During that stretch, he posted a 2.03 ERA, helping stabilize the pitching staff down the stretch and reminding evaluators of his upside.

That late-season performance likely played a role in the Mets’ willingness to include him in the Peralta trade package.

A New Beginning in New York

Tobias Myers' wife shares posts after his trade to the Mets.

Via Leah Myers' IG: pic.twitter.com/cDqvuOSuVk

— Don March (@ItsAlwaysMarch) January 23, 2026

Now, Myers begins a new chapter of his professional career with the Mets — an organization aggressively reshaping its roster in pursuit of contention.

While it remains unclear whether Myers will begin the season in the Mets’ rotation or bullpen, his versatility makes him a valuable depth option. He has experience starting, relieving, and handling high-pressure moments, including postseason appearances.

For New York, Myers represents a low-risk, potentially high-reward arm who could carve out a meaningful role depending on performance and health.

Emotional Reaction from Myers’ Wife

As news of the trade broke, Myers’ wife, Leah Angelillo, took to social media to share her reaction.

In one Instagram post, she expressed optimism and excitement about the future:

“Excited for this next chapter!”

In a follow-up Instagram Story, Angelillo offered a heartfelt message to the city where the couple began their married life:

“Thank you, Milwaukee. Next stop: the Big Apple.”

The posts reflected both gratitude and anticipation — emotions common for players’ families navigating the constant movement of professional baseball.

A Life Transition Off the Field

Myers and Angelillo were married in December 2024 at The Boca Raton hotel in Boca Raton, Florida. Less than two years later, the couple is once again preparing for a major life transition — relocating from Wisconsin to New York as Myers continues his MLB journey.

For many players, trades represent far more than roster changes. They involve uprooting homes, building new routines, and adapting to unfamiliar cities. Angelillo’s message captured that reality while embracing the opportunity ahead.

What the Trade Means for Both Teams

From Milwaukee’s perspective, the deal represents a clear shift toward retooling the roster. Moving Peralta was a difficult decision, but acquiring prospects provides long-term flexibility. Including Myers allowed the Brewers to finalize the deal while clearing rotation space for younger arms.

For the Mets, the acquisition of both Peralta and Myers signals an aggressive push to stabilize pitching depth. While Peralta headlines the move as a frontline starter, Myers gives the organization another arm capable of contributing immediately if needed.

Looking Ahead

As spring training approaches, all eyes will be on how the Mets deploy their new pitchers. Myers will enter camp with an opportunity — something not guaranteed, but certainly attainable given his past performance.

For now, the focus is on transition, preparation, and possibility.

A door has closed in Milwaukee — but another has opened in New York.

And for Tobias Myers and his family, the next chapter begins under the bright lights of the Big Apple.