The Buffalo Bills received a significant boost of hope on Sunday following their heartbreaking overtime playoff loss to the Denver Broncos, as the NFL launched an investigation into the officiating crew from Saturday’s AFC Divisional Round matchup.

NLF BREAKING NEWS (UPDATE): Good news for Buffalo Bills: 3 referees in the Bills vs. Broncos game have been summoned for questioning regarding conduct related to ‘game result manipulation’. Unless there are changes, the game result will be canceled and the game will be replayed. The NFL has also released the referees’ initial statements…

In a stunning development that has sent shockwaves through the league, three members of the officiating crew—led by referee Carl Cheffers—have been called in for formal questioning by NFL officials and league investigators. The focus centers on allegations of potential manipulation of the game’s outcome through a series of controversial calls in overtime that directly contributed to Denver’s 33-30 victory. Sources close to the situation indicate that the probe stems from widespread complaints, including from Bills personnel, about the handling of key plays that swung momentum decisively toward the Broncos.

The game itself was a high-stakes thriller at Empower Field at Mile High, with both teams trading blows throughout regulation. Buffalo quarterback Josh Allen, despite a night marred by turnovers—including two interceptions and two fumbles—kept the Bills in contention with resilient play. Denver’s Bo Nix orchestrated several strong drives, but the contest ultimately headed to overtime tied at 30-30 after Matt Prater’s late field goal for Buffalo forced the extra period.

Overtime proved to be the flashpoint. On the Bills’ first possession of the period, Allen connected with receiver Brandin Cooks on a deep pass that appeared, to many observers, to be a completed catch with Cooks going to the ground. However, Broncos cornerback Ja’Quan McMillian wrested the ball away, and officials ruled it an interception in Denver’s favor. Coach Sean McDermott immediately challenged the sequence, calling a timeout in hopes of a review, but the call stood after consultation with replay officials.

McDermott later expressed deep frustration in postgame comments and a follow-up pool report, insisting the play should have been ruled a catch and that the lack of a thorough on-field review was unacceptable for such a pivotal moment.

Denver capitalized on the turnover, marching downfield with the aid of two consecutive defensive pass interference penalties against the Bills—one on Taron Johnson and a particularly debated flag on Tre’Davious White covering Marvin Mims Jr. The penalties added crucial yardage, moving the Broncos into comfortable field goal range. White, visibly upset after the game, remarked that referees “just don’t know ball,” highlighting the perception that the calls were inconsistent with how the game had been officiated earlier. A roughing the passer flag on Joey Bosa further aided Denver’s drive.

Wil Lutz ultimately converted a chip-shot field goal to seal the win and eliminate Buffalo from postseason contention.

The aftermath saw immediate backlash from fans, analysts, and former players. Social media erupted with accusations of “rigged” officiating, with some calling it one of the worst examples of referee interference in a playoff game. Former NFL running back LeSean McCoy voiced a common sentiment, stating that officials “always kill the GREAT GAMES.” Calls for accountability grew louder as replays circulated showing the disputed plays, fueling demands for transparency from the league.

In response, the NFL has taken the unusual step of summoning the three referees for questioning over potential conduct issues tied to “game result manipulation.” While full details of the allegations remain under wraps pending the investigation, the league confirmed that initial statements from the officials have been released internally and shared with relevant parties.

These statements reportedly defend the calls as being made in real time based on the rules, with Cheffers explaining the pass interference on White as involving “early contact and an arm grab that materially restricted the receiver.” The interception ruling was upheld via replay, though critics argue the process lacked sufficient scrutiny given the stakes.

Should the investigation substantiate any impropriety or egregious errors warranting reversal, league sources suggest the result could be vacated, leading to a full replay of the game—a rare but not unprecedented measure in cases of confirmed officiating misconduct that directly alters outcomes. For Bills fans, this represents a glimmer of redemption after what felt like a stolen season. The team, led by Allen’s MVP-caliber regular season, had overcome numerous challenges to reach the divisional round, only to see their campaign end amid controversy.

As the NFL reviews the matter, the focus remains on preserving the integrity of the game. Buffalo supporters are watching closely, hopeful that justice—and perhaps another chance—could prevail. The league has promised a swift but thorough process, with further updates expected in the coming days. Until then, the Bills-Broncos saga continues to dominate headlines, underscoring ongoing concerns about consistency and accountability in NFL officiating during the league’s most critical moments.