White Sox Fans Shocked as Paul Konerko Is Left Off MLB Network’s All-Time Franchise Favorites List

The Chicago White Sox have a rich history filled with legendary players who have defined the franchise over the years. From Frank Thomas, the “Big Hurt,” to Mark Buehrle, who pitched a perfect game in 2009, the team has had a plethora of stars who have made lasting impacts. However, one crucial player, who played a key role in the White Sox’s 2005 World Series championship, was noticeably absent from MLB Network’s recent list of All-Time Franchise Favorites. That player is Paul Konerko, the long-time White Sox captain, who fans believe was snubbed in a significant oversight.

Konerko’s Absence: A Shocking Oversight for Fans

In an Instagram post by MLB Network, both Matt Vasgersian and Harold Reynolds released their choices for the White Sox’s all-time favorite players, and shockingly, Konerko’s name was missing. Given his pivotal role in Chicago’s success, including his leadership during their 2005 World Series run, many fans were taken aback by his exclusion. While Konerko wasn’t named the 2005 World Series MVP (a distinction that went to Jermaine Dye), his contributions to the team’s championship victory and his long tenure with the White Sox surely make him one of the most deserving players in franchise history.

Konerko’s absence from this prestigious list left fans questioning the reasoning behind the decision, with many expressing their disbelief in the comment section of MLB Network’s post. The reaction from the White Sox faithful makes it clear that Konerko holds a special place in their hearts, and his omission did not sit well with them.

Who Else Did Reynolds and Vasgersian Snub?

While Konerko’s exclusion was the most glaring mistake, there were other head-scratching decisions that fans pointed out. For example, at the catcher position, Vasgersian placed Jim Essian over Carlton Fisk, a Cooperstown inductee who is widely considered one of the greatest catchers in MLB history. This choice is particularly strange given Fisk’s legendary career with the White Sox, and it seemed to fly in the face of expectations for what should be a no-brainer selection.

Moreover, while A.J. Pierzynski, a key figure in the White Sox’s 2005 championship team, was not included, players like Essian—who played a limited role with the White Sox—found a spot on the list. Even more baffling was the decision not to include players like Joe Jackson, Harold Baines, or Minnie Miñoso in the outfield, as Vasgersian opted for Dan Pasqua, Mike Cameron, and Ivan Calderon instead. The exclusion of such franchise legends for these players left fans frustrated and confused about the criteria used for the list.

Controversial Designated Hitter Choices

Perhaps the most egregious omission came at the designated hitter position, where Reynolds chose Jim Thome and Vasgersian went with Lamar Johnson. While Thome is a respected figure in White Sox history, his time with the team was shorter compared to Paul Konerko, who spent 16 seasons in Chicago. Thome was a productive hitter during his stint with the White Sox, but Konerko’s longevity and consistent production in the lineup over the years made him a far more deserving candidate for the spot.

Vasgersian’s selection of Lamar Johnson, who hit just 57 home runs in his White Sox career, was especially puzzling to fans. The decision seemed out of place, as Konerko’s 432 home runs in a White Sox uniform and his legendary moments in the 2005 World Series undoubtedly make him a more fitting choice for the team’s designated hitter, if not a better fit overall.

Why Konerko Deserves the Spot

Paul Konerko’s legacy with the White Sox is undeniable, and his inclusion on any list of all-time franchise favorites should be a given. Konerko spent 16 seasons with the team, becoming one of the most beloved figures in White Sox history. His accomplishments are staggering: six-time All-Star, 2005 ALCS MVP, and one of the most consistent and clutch hitters the franchise has ever seen. His 432 home runs and countless memorable moments, including his grand slam in the 2005 World Series, solidified his place as a White Sox legend.

While Konerko’s defense may not have been his strongest suit, his bat and leadership made him the heart of the team for years. His contributions to the White Sox’s 2005 World Series championship—alongside his role as the team’s captain—have made him a fixture in the memories of Chicago fans. His grand slam in Game 2 of the World Series was one of the most iconic moments in White Sox history, and it remains a highlight for fans who witnessed it.

Beyond his on-field performance, Konerko’s impact on the team and its fans cannot be overstated. He became a symbol of consistency and leadership in the clubhouse, and he was widely respected for his work ethic and professionalism. His number has been retired by the White Sox, and he even has a statue at Guaranteed Rate Field, further cementing his status as a franchise icon.

A True Fan-Favorite: Konerko’s Impact on White Sox Fans

For fans who grew up watching Konerko, he represented the heart and soul of the team for over a decade. His reliability in clutch situations, his leadership on and off the field, and his lasting impact on the 2005 World Series team have made him a fan favorite for generations of White Sox supporters. The fact that his exclusion from MLB Network’s All-Time Franchise Favorites list has sparked such an emotional response from fans only underscores the deep connection he has with the team’s faithful.

Konerko’s absence from this list is a glaring oversight in the eyes of White Sox fans, and it’s clear that he is deserving of recognition as one of the franchise’s all-time greats. His legacy in Chicago is secure, regardless of this snub, but it’s hard to ignore how deeply fans feel about his place in the team’s history.

Conclusion: Konerko’s Legacy is Unquestionable

In the end, the exclusion of Paul Konerko from MLB Network’s All-Time Franchise Favorites list is a head-scratcher, especially when considering his lengthy tenure with the White Sox, his role in the team’s only World Series championship since 1917, and his iconic moments that continue to resonate with fans today. As one of the franchise’s true legends, Konerko’s place in White Sox history is unquestionable, and his status as a fan-favorite will forever be secured in the hearts of Chicago supporters.

For White Sox fans, the debate over his omission will continue, but Konerko’s legacy in Chicago will never be overshadowed by this oversight.