Could a Familiar Face Solve the Minnesota Twins’ Roster Puzzle?
Over three months into the offseason, the Minnesota Twins have been actively reshaping their roster, particularly focusing on position players. So far, the team has made strategic moves to add depth and versatility: trading for Alex Jackson to serve as a backup catcher behind Christian Vázquez, signing veteran switch-hitter Josh Bell to man first base and the designated hitter role, and acquiring Ryan Kreidler, Eric Wagaman, and Orlando Arcia to bolster the team’s depth options.
These additions bring crucial experience and flexibility to a roster headlined by Byron Buxton, Royce Lewis, Luke Keaschall, Ryan Jeffers, Matt Wallner, Brooks Lee, and other emerging talents. With these core players in place, the Twins are nearly finished assembling their 13-player major-league position player group. The remaining players are mostly depth options likely to start the season at Triple-A St. Paul, ready to step in in the event of injury or other roster needs.
Yet despite this progress, Minnesota still faces one lingering question: could they benefit from adding one more versatile, reliable bench bat? Ideally, this player would fill a super-utility role, capable of covering both infield and outfield positions. And if that sounds familiar, there’s a good reason why: Willi Castro, a former Twin, fits that exact profile.
The Rise and Fall of Willi Castro
Willi Castro signed a minor-league deal with the Twins before the 2023 season, entering Minnesota as a relatively unheralded veteran. What followed was a career renaissance. Over 1,388 plate appearances, Castro posted a combined 107 wRC+ while playing meaningful innings at six different positions—including multiple relief appearances on the infield and outfield. His versatility and offensive contributions were critical to Minnesota’s roster flexibility, making him one of the most valuable “glue players” on the team.
However, Castro’s journey took a dramatic turn at the 2025 trade deadline when he was sent to the Chicago Cubs. In Chicago, Castro struggled mightily at the plate, hitting just .170/.245/.240 with a 40 wRC+ over 110 plate appearances. While he continued to provide defensive versatility, his offensive shortcomings kept him off playoff rosters and signaled a disappointing end to his tenure with the Cubs.
Before the 2025 season, Castro was projected to earn a multi-year contract exceeding $10 million annually. Now, after a challenging stint in Chicago, his market value has dropped significantly. Analysts predict he could command a one-year deal worth between $3 million and $5 million, a figure well within the Twins’ salary-restricted budget. For Minnesota, Castro represents a rare opportunity: a former fan favorite with proven versatility who could fill critical gaps in the roster at an affordable price.
Filling Minnesota’s Positional Gaps
In 2025, Castro played six positions for the Twins, including second base, third base, and both corner outfield spots. This versatility could address several areas of need for Minnesota in 2026.
Outfield Depth
The Twins boast solid corner outfield options in Matt Wallner, Trevor Larnach, Austin Martin, Alan Roden, and James Outman, with top prospects Walker Jenkins and Emmanuel Rodriguez starting the season at Triple-A St. Paul. While the outfield depth is strong, Castro’s balanced switch-hitting ability makes him an appealing right-handed platoon option for left or right field, particularly against certain pitching matchups.
Infield Flexibility
On the infield, Castro could serve as a backup at third base, stepping in for Royce Lewis when needed, and contribute at second base alongside Luke Keaschall and Kody Clemens. While his days as a shortstop and center fielder may be behind him, he remains a strong emergency option at shortstop, potentially providing a superior offensive alternative to depth players like Kreidler or Arcia. By bringing Castro back, the Twins could reduce reliance on their less proven depth options, giving the team more flexibility and insurance against injuries.
First Base Potential
Although Castro did not play first base in 2025 despite speculation, Minnesota could consider giving him opportunities there in 2026. With Josh Bell’s defensive limitations and Clemens and Wagaman as more marginal options, a veteran like Castro could offer reliable, affordable versatility. While he may not replicate the All-Star-level success he experienced in 2024, his ability to cover multiple positions and provide a steady bat makes him a smart addition for a team managing both performance and payroll.
Why Castro Makes Sense for the Twins
Several factors make Castro a compelling candidate to rejoin the Twins:
-
Affordable Option: His projected one-year deal falls comfortably within the Twins’ budget constraints, allowing Minnesota to add experience without overcommitting financially.
-
Versatility: Castro can play second base, third base, left field, right field, and serve as an emergency shortstop. This flexibility is invaluable in the long grind of a 162-game season.
-
Familiarity: Returning to Minnesota offers continuity for both Castro and the organization. He already understands the team’s culture, coaching staff, and expectations, which reduces the risk of adjustment struggles.
-
Clubhouse Chemistry: Beyond statistics, Castro is well-liked in the clubhouse, a factor that can impact team cohesion and morale—often overlooked but crucial over the long season.
-
Offensive Upgrade: While not an All-Star anymore, Castro is a better offensive option than Kreidler, Arcia, or Wagaman, particularly against right-handed pitching, providing a reliable alternative when the team needs depth.
Strategic Fit in 2026
By bringing back Castro, the Twins could round out their major-league roster more effectively, ensuring a balance of youth, veteran experience, and positional coverage. His presence would give Minnesota more options to manage injuries, platoon situations, and late-inning substitutions without overburdening younger players or relying solely on the Triple-A roster.
For example, Brooks Lee could have a dependable backup at shortstop, Royce Lewis could rotate through third base with Castro as a substitute, and the corner outfield could feature matchups optimized by Castro’s switch-hitting ability. Even if he doesn’t play every day, his role as a utility player could be the key to keeping Minnesota’s position player group fresh and competitive throughout the long season.
Conclusion
The Minnesota Twins have done a solid job of adding depth and versatility this offseason, but one final addition—a familiar, affordable, and versatile player—could make a significant difference. Willi Castro fits that description perfectly. His proven ability to handle multiple positions, combined with an affordable salary and positive clubhouse presence, makes him a logical candidate to solve Minnesota’s remaining roster puzzle.
While he may no longer be the breakout All-Star he once was, Castro offers reliability, flexibility, and experience—all qualities the Twins need as they aim to compete in the American League Central. Bringing him back could be the smart, cost-effective move that positions Minnesota for success in 2026, ensuring the team has the depth to weather injuries, optimize matchups, and remain competitive throughout the season.
For Twins fans and MLB analysts alike, watching how Minnesota approaches the final pieces of its roster will be critical—and keeping an eye on Willi Castro might just provide the answer to the team’s biggest lingering question: how to finish assembling a complete, versatile, and competitive lineup without breaking the bank.
