Cubs’ Alex Bregman Blockbuster Could Trigger Major Roster Shake-Up as Nico Hoerner Emerges in Trade Rumors
Landing Alex Bregman stands as one of the most significant moves of the Chicago Cubs offseason, a signing that immediately altered expectations both inside the organization and across the National League.
Bregman’s arrival brought instant credibility to Chicago’s infield, adding a proven postseason performer, elite defender, and impact bat to a roster that has been steadily trending upward.
But it also came at a steep cost.
At $35 million per year over five seasons, the Cubs are now operating dangerously close to the Competitive Balance Tax threshold, a financial reality that could force difficult decisions sooner rather than later.
With the initial excitement settling, a more complicated question now dominates the conversation around the Cubs.
What comes next?
CBT Pressure Looms Large After Bregman Signing
The Cubs’ 2026 CBT threshold is set at $244 million, and Chicago currently sits just under $243 million, placing the organization within striking distance of the luxury tax line.
That margin leaves little room for flexibility.
And according to MLB insider Peter Appel, the Bregman deal may have effectively pushed the front office toward a consequential roster decision.
To stay under the CBT line, Chicago may need to trade a veteran player with a sizable salary.
A move that could ease financial pressure.
But one that also risks disrupting the chemistry and on-field stability the Cubs worked hard to establish.
Nico Hoerner’s Name Surfaces in Trade Speculation
Appel believes the Cubs’ internal debate may come down to a familiar front-office dilemma.
Cheap, controllable talent versus established veterans.
And in that debate, Nico Hoerner has emerged as a focal point.
“I know Ricketts is seeing that $800,000 and $20,000 salary, with plenty of years of control, and saying he doesn’t want to trade him,” Appel wrote on X.
“I want to trade the guy who’s making $12 million dollars this year and is a free agent next year. Nico Hoerner.”
Appel added that his concern goes even deeper.
He fears the Cubs could not only trade Hoerner, but do so primarily for prospects, allowing Chicago to recoup some of what it surrendered in the Edward Cabrera trade while avoiding additional financial commitments.
From a business perspective, the logic is clear.
From a baseball perspective, it is far more complicated.
Hoerner’s Value to the Cubs Cannot Be Ignored
Hoerner has spent seven seasons with the Cubs and remains one of the most reliable players on the roster.
In 2025, he was a cornerstone of the lineup, batting .297, collecting 178 hits, and driving in 61 RBIs.
Those numbers are not easily replaced.
Beyond the stat sheet, Hoerner brings elite defense and consistency.
He is a two-time Gold Glove winner, widely respected for his instincts, positioning, and leadership in the middle infield.
He is also entering the final year of his contract, which naturally raises questions about whether Chicago should capitalize on his peak trade value before free agency.
Matt Shaw’s Development Adds Another Layer of Complexity
The Cubs’ infield puzzle becomes even more intricate when factoring in Matt Shaw.
Last season, Hoerner held down second base while Shaw settled in as the everyday third baseman.
Now, with Bregman locked in at third base, Shaw becomes the positional odd man out in the short term.
Shaw’s rookie MLB campaign was uneven.
He hit .226 with 13 home runs, showing flashes of promise but also the expected growing pains of a first-year player.
Moving on from Shaw at this stage would be a major gamble.
He remains a long-term piece in the Cubs’ plans and has also logged time at second base, creating positional flexibility.
But that flexibility comes with consequences.
If Shaw shifts to second base, Hoerner’s role becomes less clear.
And that is where trade rumors begin to gain traction.
The Financial Case for Trading Hoerner
From a purely financial standpoint, moving Hoerner is difficult to argue against.
Trading him would clear roughly $35 million from the Cubs’ future payroll obligations.
That move alone would almost guarantee Chicago remains under the CBT threshold.
For an ownership group led by Tom Ricketts, known for exercising caution around luxury tax penalties, the appeal is obvious.
Avoiding the CBT preserves long-term flexibility and prevents escalating tax rates in future seasons.
But baseball decisions are rarely that simple.
The On-Field Risk of a Veteran-for-Prospects Deal
While trading Hoerner would strengthen the Cubs’ farm system, it would also weaken the major-league roster in the short term.
Even with Bregman anchoring third base, removing Hoerner would strip Chicago of one of its most dependable everyday players.
Veteran leadership matters.
Defensive stability matters.
Contact hitters who rarely strike out matter.
Replacing those traits with prospects introduces volatility, especially for a team aiming to contend now rather than later.
Yankees Emerge as a Logical Trade Partner
If the Cubs do decide to move Hoerner, the New York Yankees stand out as a natural match.
New York possesses a deep collection of intriguing young talent, including:
-
Spencer Jones
-
Carlos Lagrange
-
Elmer Rodriguez
For Chicago, such a return could significantly bolster the farm system.
For New York, Hoerner offers an immediate upgrade.
Why Hoerner Makes Sense for the Yankees
The Yankees recently missed out on Cody Bellinger, leaving a void in both versatility and consistency.
Hoerner could help fill that gap.
He is an elite defender.
A legitimate speed threat.
And one of the most difficult outs in baseball.
His 7.6 percent strikeout rate ranked in the 99th percentile league-wide, making him the type of contact-first hitter New York has historically lacked.
The advanced metrics are equally compelling.
According to FanGraphs, Hoerner posted a 4.9 WAR last season.
That is the same mark Bellinger produced.
From a value perspective, the comparison is striking.
A Potential Win-Win — With a Catch
On paper, a Hoerner trade could benefit both franchises.
The Cubs would strengthen their long-term outlook with high-end prospects and relieve CBT pressure.
The Yankees would land a reliable, well-rounded player who improves their defense, contact profile, and lineup balance.
The cost, however, is real.
Chicago would lose the advantage of fielding both Hoerner and Bregman in the same infield — a combination that could have been one of the most stable and productive units in the National League.
Final Outlook: A Decision That Defines the Cubs’ Direction
The Alex Bregman signing signaled that the Cubs are serious about competing.
But it also placed the organization at a crossroads.
Trade a proven veteran to protect financial flexibility.
Or accept CBT risk in pursuit of immediate success.
If Nico Hoerner is moved, it will not be a reflection of his value as a player.
It will be a reflection of modern roster economics.
The next few months will reveal whether the Cubs prioritize stability now — or sustainability later.
Either way, Bregman’s arrival has already reshaped Chicago’s future.
The question is how much further that ripple will travel.
