Rookie quarterbacks usually get eased in. Training wheels on. Reads simplified. Expectations managed.

That wasn’t the case for Tyler Shough, and that’s exactly why he should win NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year.

From the start, the New Orleans Saints put the offense in his hands. This wasn’t a conservative, run-first approach meant to protect a rookie. The Saints leaned into the passing game and trusted Shough to drive it. He rewarded that trust with poise, precision, and control well beyond his experience level.

Shough played like a quarterback who knew where the ball needed to go before it was snapped. He worked through progressions, manipulated defenders with his eyes, and delivered throws on time. When defenses brought pressure, he stood in and made the right decision. When they backed off, he stayed patient and took what was there.

Tyler Shough was the perfect pick by the Saints. This will allow the Saints to rebuild a solid roster without worrying about having a poor QB and I could really see this team having a wildcard spot next year.

pic.twitter.com/TGCTsDZ7Tj — Film Watchers (@Filmwatchers1) December 22, 2025

What separated him from other rookies was command. Shough ran the offense, not the other way around. He set protections. He adjusted plays at the line. He kept the tempo steady. The Saints didn’t look like a team surviving a rookie season at quarterback. They looked organized, confident, and comfortable throwing the ball because their quarterback was in control.

The passing game flowed through him, and it showed. Receivers stayed in rhythm. Drives stayed alive. Mistakes were limited. Shough didn’t chase big plays at the expense of the offense. He understood when to attack and when to manage, a balance that most rookies struggle to find.

There was also no mistaking the leadership. Shough carried himself like the quarterback. Teammates followed. The huddle responded. When things got tight, the ball stayed in his hands, and the Saints didn’t hesitate to ask him to make the play.

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year isn’t just about highlights or raw numbers. It’s about impact. Shough gave the Saints something they’ve been searching for: stability, direction, and belief at the most important position on the field.

Rookies can flash. Franchise quarterbacks take charge. This season, Tyler Shough did both.