🔥 MLB FREE AGENCY ALERT: Yankees Suddenly Eyeing a Blue Jays All‑Star Instead of Bellinger—Is It Due to Health Risks, Contract Costs, or a Bold Strategic Gambit That Could Shock the Baseball World? 👇

Cody Bellinger’s Free Agency Saga: Will the Yankees Shift Focus to Bo Bichette?

The New York Yankees have been actively involved in the offseason market, but their pursuit of Cody Bellinger has not been as straightforward as many fans hoped. After coming off an impressive 2025 season, his best since winning the Most Valuable Player award with the Los Angeles Dodgers in 2019, Bellinger has re-entered the market with high expectations. He is seeking a long-term deal, and so far, only the Toronto Blue Jays have been willing to meet his demands. This has left many wondering if the Yankees will be able to secure his services or if they will pivot to other options, like Bo Bichette.

Bellinger’s Free-Agent Situation: A Long-Term Commitment in High Demand

Cody Bellinger, after returning to form in 2025 with a .275 batting average, 32 home runs, and 98 RBIs, has placed himself among the top free agents on the market. His performance has revived his career after a few seasons of struggle, and now, the 28-year-old center fielder is looking for a contract that reflects his return to form.

However, what’s holding back teams, including the Yankees, from making a move is Bellinger’s asking price. He is reportedly seeking a long-term commitment from a team, potentially for five or more years, and that has raised concerns for some organizations. While his talent is undeniable, the size of the deal is proving to be a hurdle.

At this stage, the Toronto Blue Jays are the only team that appears willing to offer Bellinger the contract he desires. The Yankees, however, have not shown the same level of commitment, leading some to believe they might pursue a different path.

Bellinger’s Market and the Yankees’ Strategy

According to reports from Manny Gómez of NJ Advance Media, the Yankees’ reluctance to meet Bellinger’s contract demands could be tied to their interest in another star free agent — Bo Bichette of the Toronto Blue Jays. Bichette, a dynamic shortstop with a proven track record of success, could be a natural fit for the Yankees, who are looking to upgrade their lineup.

The Yankees have been linked to Bichette for several months now, with Jon Heyman of the New York Post reporting that the Yankees are exploring a potential move for the shortstop. Bichette, who had an impressive 2025 season with 32 home runs, 103 RBIs, and a .290 batting average, is currently one of the top infielders available in free agency. His positional flexibility and ability to make an immediate impact on both offense and defense make him a valuable asset for any team.

Could Bichette Be the Yankees’ Pivot?

Bichette’s potential move to the Yankees has gained traction, particularly as the team contemplates whether Bellinger’s price tag is too high. Bellinger, who is asking for a contract that could exceed $200 million over several years, might be too expensive for the Yankees, especially considering their payroll flexibility and long-term financial commitments to other players like Aaron Judge and Gerrit Cole.

Buster Olney of ESPN speculated that the Yankees may already have a lower offer on the table for Bellinger, possibly in the range of five years, $130 million, which Olney describes as “essentially a pay cut” from what Bellinger may have expected. This offer is reportedly far below what Bellinger believes he’s worth, and this discrepancy could lead the Yankees to pivot toward other options, such as pursuing Bichette.

Why Bichette Makes Sense for the Yankees

The Yankees’ interest in Bo Bichette could make a lot of sense for several reasons:

• Positional Flexibility: Bichette can play shortstop and second base, giving the Yankees flexibility in their infield. With Gleyber Torres already at second base, Bichette could take over shortstop or provide a dynamic duo in the middle infield alongside Torres.

• Offensive Production: Bichette has been one of the most consistent offensive performers for the Blue Jays, providing power, contact, and the ability to drive in runs. His .290 batting average and ability to hit for extra bases would provide the Yankees with another bat in the lineup to support Judge and Torres.

• Defensive Upgrade: Bichette’s defense at shortstop has improved over the years, and his range and arm strength would be an upgrade for the Yankees’ infield, which has had occasional struggles with defense.

• Long-Term Fit: Bichette is only 25 years old, meaning he could be a long-term solution for the Yankees at shortstop or second base. This fits well with the Yankees’ desire to build a sustainable contender for the future.

The Yankees’ 2026 Offseason Outlook: What’s Next?

As the offseason continues, the New York Yankees find themselves at a crossroads. Bellinger could still be a target, but with the high cost associated with his potential contract, the Yankees may look elsewhere. Bo Bichette presents a more cost-effective option that could provide both immediate and long-term benefits for the team.

With a deep payroll and a commitment to winning now, the Yankees will likely continue to pursue the best available options to enhance their roster. While Bellinger remains a tempting target due to his star power and offensive contributions, Bichette’s age, versatility, and ability to fill a positional need could be exactly what the Yankees need to move forward.

For fans, it’s clear that the Yankees are making significant moves this offseason to strengthen their lineup and ensure they remain competitive in the American League. Whether it’s Bellinger or Bichette, the team is focused on returning to the World Series, and both players could be key pieces in that journey.

Conclusion: Will the Yankees Pivot to Bichette?

As the offseason progresses, the New York Yankees will have to decide if they want to invest heavily in Cody Bellinger or make a shift toward Bo Bichette. While Bellinger’s high asking price might be a roadblock, Bichette offers a solid alternative that could address the Yankees’ needs both offensively and defensively.

The decision to pivot toward Bichette could allow the Yankees to build a more balanced and flexible roster heading into the 2026 season, with the possibility of a more team-friendly contract that also provides long-term stability at a key position. It’s clear that the Yankees are not afraid to make bold moves, and this offseason will be critical in shaping the team’s future.