Francisco Lindor Joins A Select Club With An MVP-Caliber Season In The Shadow Of An All-Timer

Francisco Lindor Joins A Select Club With An MVP-Caliber Season In The  Shadow Of An All-Timer

Shohei Ohtani didn’t double during the NL Championship Series and stopped at second base just five times during the Dodgers’ six-game triumph over the Mets. So chances are Mets shortstop Francisco Lindor did not get to good-naturedly admonish Ohtani for overshadowing the best season of his career, a la Cecil Cooper with George Brett more than 44 years earlier.

Brett’s pursuit of a .400 season peaked on Aug. 26, 1980, when he went 5-for-5 for the Royals in a 7-6 win over the Brewers in Milwaukee. The outburst lifted Brett’s average from .398 to .407, a mark no qualified batter has reached that late in a season since.

But “just” one of Brett’s hits went for extra bases, which meant he had lots of time to catch up with Brewers first baseman Cecil Cooper, who was in the midst of a a stretch of seven straight .300 seasons and enjoying a career-best year.

But Cooper’s 2-for-5 effort that Tuesday night kept his average to .356 — and left him 51 points behind Brett in an AL batting race that Brett had long turned into the baseball version of the 1973 Belmont Stakes.

“My last hit was a single and Cecil’s playing first base and Cecil’s hitting .340, .350 at the time,” Brett said during an interview in late September. “And I got that fifth and I’m standing on first base. He says ‘(Jiminy Christmas), at least give me a chance, will ya?’”

Brett laughed.

“I’ll never forget that one,” Brett said.

Lindor officially joined Cooper and numerous other stars in the great-but-not-great-enough club last Thursday, when Ohtani unanimously won the NL MVP award.

The result wasn’t a surprise, though there was a window in August and September in which it appeared Lindor, a Gold Glove-caliber shortstop even if he wasn’t a Gold Glove finalist this season, might make a run at Ohtani, who played the entire season at designated hitter.

At the least, Lindor’s all-around skills as he helped the Mets overcome a slow start and reach the playoffs opened up the old debate about whether the MVP should actually be renamed the MOP (Most Outstanding Player).

“I would (say) ‘OK, what would happen to the Mets if you took Lindor off their team?’” Brett said. “And if you take Ohtani off their team, where would they finish? And then I would vote for whoever I thought was more valuable to that team winning the division or getting to the playoffs. To me, that’s what the most valuable player is.

“They could have a most outstanding player, they could have the best year, but most valuable to their team? And I think that gets overlooked. You take Ohtani away from the Dodgers, are they still going to win their division? You take Lindor away from the Mets, are they going to be here they are without him?”

Any chance Lindor had at catching Ohtani — or at least getting a first-place vote — disappeared form Sept. 14-26, when Lindor missed eight of nine games with a back injury. While the Mets went 6-3 in their games without Lindor, Ohtani hit an otherworldly .490 (!!!) with six homers, 22 RBIs and eight stolen bases in as many attempts over 12 games. On Sept. 19, Ohtani established the 50/50 club by hitting three homers, stealing two bases and adding 10 RBIs in a 6-for-6 performance against the Marlins.

“Fifty/fifty doesn’t come around very often,” Brett said in the understatement of the year.

Seasons like Lindor’s, on the other hand, are fairly common. Lindor joins the likes of Mike Greenwell (1988 AL behind Jose Canseco), Tino Martinez (1997 AL behind Ken Griffey Jr), Bret Boone (2001 AL third, behind winner Ichiro Suzuki and Jason Giambi), Mark Teixeira (2009 AL behind Joe Mauer) and Daniel Murphy (2016 NL behind Kris Bryant) as stars whose best seasons were overshadowed by a unanimous or near-unanimous MVP winner.

As for Cooper? He finished FIFTH in 1980 behind Brett, who got 17 of 26 first-place votes, as well as two more Hall of Famers (Reggie Jackson and Goose Gossage) and Brett’s teammate Willie Wilson. Cooper, who hit .352 with an AL-high 122 RBIs and 335 total bases, didn’t even get a first-place vote. The last one went to Yankees catcher Rick Cerone, who finished seventh.

Cooper had two more top-5 MVP finishes, but Greenwell, Martinez, Boone, Teixeira and Murphy never came close to winning the MVP again. Now Lindor, 31, just has to hope he’s got at least one more season like the one Paul Goldschmidt had in 2022, when the two-time NL MVP runner-up finally took home the prize by hitting .317 with 35 homers and 115 RBIs along with an NL-best .578 slugging percentage and .981 OPS for the Cardinals.

Of course, it’ll be a big help to Lindor — and everyone else in the NL — if Ohtani decides to give anyone else a chance.

Related Posts

Red Sox’s Aroldis Chapman pulled from Dodgers clash with back injury

Red Sox reliever Aroldis Chapman left Sunday’s game with a back injury. Boston was still able to close out a one-run win.

Chapman leaves with injury, teammates step up as Red Sox take series from Dodgers

Aroldis Chapman, the Boston Red Sox’ All-Star closer, left Sunday’s game with an injury, but his teammates stepped up to help close out the Los Angeles Dodgers 4-3 to take the weekend series from the reigning World Series champions. The Sox won the series 2-1, with Jordan Hicks closing out the game after Chapman was forced to leave. Hicks got a huge assist from second baseman Ceddanne Rafaela, who had an unassisted double play to end the 8th inning. Red Sox manager Alex Cora said after the game

Yankees rumors: Why New York traded for Ryan McMahon over Eugenio Suarez

New information is coming out about why the New York Yankees reached a deal for Ryan McMahon, and not Eugenio Suarez.

Cubs Reportedly Willing to Include Top Prospect in Mitch Keller Blockbuster Deal

The Chicago Cubs have been expected for weeks leading up to the trade deadline to get aggressive in making upgrades.

This under-the-radar White Sox pitcher could be perfect Yankees trade deadline fit

Amidst a flurry of high-profile trade rumors, this under-the-radar White Sox pitcher could be a perfect for the Yankees at the 2025 MLB trade deadline.

Braves rumors: Atlanta open to trade of 3-time All-Star, with a catch

The Atlanta Braves reportedly are willing to trade one of their fan favorite players, but maybe not right now.