Apparently, the New York Yankees want to lower their payroll below $300 million. Or at least that’s what we’ve been told.

But if that’s the case, then how should we make much sense of the reporting concerning the Yankees at the MLB Winter Meetings?

Advertisement

Mark Feinsand of MLB.com has revealed that New York is in on pitchers Tatsuya Imai and Michael King this winter, which flies in the face of the payroll speculation.

Imai is expected to bag a deal worth in the neighborhood of $200 million, and King could net over $100 million, especially after his former teammate, Dylan Cease, secured a seven-year, $210 million contract from the Toronto Blue Jays.

Explain how the Yankees will be fielding a sub-$300 million payroll if they make either of those additions?

Not only that, but New York is also said to be the frontrunner for Cody Bellinger, who smashed 29 home runs while logging 98 RBI in the Bronx this past season.

There is no way the Yankees will be able to sign a big-name pitcher and retain Bellinger while still slashing money. The only path to doing so is by trading away one of their top money makers, and that simply isn’t happening.

Advertisement

This is why we need to be careful of what rumors we digest during the MLB offseason, especially when it pertains to the Yanks.

The Bronx Bombers are known for being rather secretive with how they operate during the winter (and in general, really), so all of the payroll rumors seem to be on big smokescreen on the part of New York’s front office.

As I stated previously, the Yankees won 94 games in 2025. They finished second in the AL East and were then bounced by the Blue Jays in the ALDS. How can they decrease payroll and expect to seriously contend next season? It doesn’t make sense.

The Yankees aren’t the Tampa Bay Rays. They don’t just make low-cost moves to stay afloat. This is a proud organization that is aiming to win World Series titles every year, and even if Hal Steinbrenner is not quite as spendthrift as his late father, I still can’t imagine him sitting on his hands and doing nothing this offseason.

Will Kyle Tucker be coming to New York? Probably not, but the idea of the Yankees not spending money at all always seemed ludicrous to me.