Ex-Yankees question Aaron Judge’s relationship with Juan Soto: Are you really boys?

How much influence will New York Yankees outfielder Aaron Judge have on Juan Soto’s free agency decision? Nobody knows for sure, but it could go beyond their on-field production of one season in pinstripes.

And if Judge’s offseason efforts are to be assessed — he told reporters last week he hasn’t talked to Soto since the end of the World Series on Oct. 30 — he isn’t doing enough, two former Yankees believe.

Upon hearing Judge’s comments about a lack of communication, ex-third baseman Todd Frazier and ex-catcher Erik Kratz expressed disappointment on Monday’s “Foul Territory,” saying Judge should be a more central part of the Yankees’ Soto negotiations.

“They should bring Judge back into a meeting,” Frazier said. “They should do everything possible to get this guy to go to the Yankees. … I’d be calling every day. ‘Hey, can we talk again? What do you got going on?’ … I’m not saying it’s wrong what he’s doing, but I think, I would do a little bit more. I would try at least once. I wouldn’t berate him and hound him as much, but you know … it’s give him a text, ‘Yankees?’ ‘Hey, the Boogie Down still loves you.’

According to NJ Advance Media’s Bob Klapisch, via a person with knowledge, the Yankees were “encouraged” by their meeting on Nov. 18, though owner Hal Steinbrenner told reporters days later that he had “no idea” where the Yankees stand.

Kratz expected more from Judge this offseason, going as far as to question the strength of the relationship, though he acknowledged that might be their style on business decisions.

“I don’t want to go too far into like, maybe they didn’t connect over the year. If somebody’s my boy, I am hounding him to stay with my team,” Kratz said. “Sure. I am hounding him to be like, ‘Hey, we can’t screw this up.’ And sometimes when guys come over for one year, they don’t always make that connection for one season.

“Obviously, I’m going so far into it here, I’m not, you know, I could be stepping out of bounds by saying that, but I would like somebody to sell me on ‘stay with a team,’ but I also don’t think that’s what he’s looking for. I don’t think that’s what Juan’s necessarily looking for.

The truth is that nobody knows Soto’s preferences. Reporting around Soto’s free agency suggests that the 26-year-old will be looking for the biggest payday, in terms of length of deal and money. Soto declining a 15-year $440 million deal in 2022 with the Washington Nationals and Scott Boras as his agent add to that belief. His next deal is likely to be for at least 13 years and $600 million.

A person with knowledge of the situation told NJ Advance Media’s Randy Miller on Monday that Soto has received first offers from the Yankees, New York Mets, Boston Red Sox and Los Angeles Dodgers. Many expect Soto to sign around the Winter Meetings on Dec. 9-12.

Soto hit a career-high 41 home runs last year with the Yankees, while posting a .288/.419/.569 slash line with 109 RBIs. He had a 178 OPS+.

If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

Related Posts

Determining Hypothetical New Contract Between Braves and Ha-Seong Kim

Should Ha-Seong Kim choose to opt out, here is what the Atlanta Braves will likely pay to keep him around

Red Sox Cut Ties With 4-Year Member Of Coaching Staff: Report

The administrative business of the offseason has begun in earnest for the Boston Red Sox. After a season in which they improved, made the playoffs, but still le

Ex-Yankees outfielder named option to replace Aaron Boone

The New York Yankees manager could find himself out of a job after another disappointing season.

Why Chicago Cubs’ Bitter NL Foe Is Kyle Tucker’s Top Free Agency Destination

If Kyle Tucker isn’t going to re-sign with the Chicago Cubs upon becoming an unrestricted free agent this offseason, Cubs fans would surely hope that he joins a

Pirates claim outfielder Will Robertson off waivers from White Sox, DFA Ryan Kreidler

The Pittsburgh Pirates added an outfielder who flashed some power in the minor leagues by claiming Will Robertson off waivers Monday from the Chicago White Sox. The…

Braves’ search for Brian Snitker’s replacement hits roadblock after shocking Padres decision

The Braves quest for a new top manager may have just hit a huge road block.