Blockbuster Trade Idea Sends Mets $80 Million Pete Alonso Replacement

Although the New York Mets are involved in the Juan Soto free agency sweepstakes, president of baseball operations David Stearns has other roster issues to address. There’s a hole at first base since homegrown slugger Pete Alonso is also on the open market. If the Polar Bear doesn’t return to Queens, what kind of alternatives are available for the Mets?

There are other players to pursue via free agency, including Christian Walker and Paul Goldschmidt. The club could also get creative by signing Alex Bregman or Willy Adames to play third base and shift Mark Vientos over to first.

New York Mets first baseman Pete Alonso
NEW YORK, NEW YORK – OCTOBER 18: Pete Alonso #20 of the New York Mets rounds the bases after hitting a three-run home run in the first inning against the Los Angeles Dodgers during Game…  Al Bello/Getty Images

Filling this hole via the trade market is another idea. One of the most prominent position players available on that front is Chicago Cubs outfielder/first baseman Cody Bellinger. He signed a three-year, $80 million deal in February to stay in the Windy City and decided against opting out to re-test free agency this winter.

While Bellinger wants to stay with the Cubs, the organization may not feel the same way. The Mets are seen as the “clear cut favorite” to land Soto. While New York could afford both Soto and Alonso, it might not happen.

If the Mets do need a new first baseman, FanSided’s Joshua Ambroise thinks Stearns should target Bellinger to take his place. The 2019 National League MVP Award winner slashed .266/.325/.426 with 18 home runs, 23 doubles, 78 RBI and 72 runs scored in 2024 for the Cubs. That would be a drop-off in the power department compared to Alonso, but he certainly would be a solid offensive contributor and has a good defensive reputation.

He also knows a thing or two about playing in a big market and performing in October. “Bellinger even understands the tasks of handling the big market teams. Before he was a Cub, Cody spent the first six seasons in Dodgers uniform,” Ambroise wrote. “He won multiple honor awards which includes the NL Rookie of the Year, NLCS MVP, NL MVP and a World Series championship. Handling another big-market team like New York shouldn’t pose a problem, as history has shown.”

Related Posts

Breaking: Braves outfielder Jurickson Profar has quietly mastered the art of the “private sanctuary.” Since arriving in Atlanta, the switch-hitter has kept his wife and four children—including a newborn born in September 2025—entirely out of the spotlight, anchoring family life in deep ties to Curaçao and the Dominican Republic. In an era of constant exposure, Profar’s choice to shield his inner circle feels intentional—and increasingly rare

Atlanta, January 25, 2026 – Jurickson Profar, the veteran switch-hitting outfielder who broke out as an All-Star with the San Diego Padres in 2024 (.280 AVG, 24…

LATEST UPDATE: With his Hall of Fame window still open, Chris Sale enters a defining season in Atlanta. This isn’t about what he used to be—it’s about proving he still belongs among the game’s elite. One more standout year could turn a fading question into a lasting legacy

There is a quiet urgency building around Chris Sale, the kind that doesn’t come from desperation but from awareness. His Hall of Fame case is already strong,…

Breaking Baseball Buzz: Atlanta Braves vs Kansas City Royals at Truist Park – Unbelievable New 7:15 PM Eastern Kickoff Time Set to Ignite Fans, Weather Forecast, Broadcast Info & What Every Steelers Fan Must Know for This Epic Spring Baseball Event

Breaking Baseball Buzz: Atlanta Braves vs Kansas City Royals at Truist Park – Unbelievable New 7:15 PM Eastern Kickoff Time Set to Ignite Fans, Weather Forecast, Broadcast Info…

Report: Twins Territory’s most criticized left-handed corner outfielder may finally be turning a corner—and 2026 could be the payoff. After years of frustration and uneven production, signs are emerging that a breakout season isn’t out of the question. The question now isn’t if the Twins should move on, but whether patience might finally be rewarded

Please Don’t Overlook Trevor Larnach: Why the Twins Still Have a Valuable Bat Hiding in Plain Sight Entering the offseason, many who closely follow the Minnesota Twins…

TOP STORY: Sun, sand, and stardom as Chloe Holliday enjoys a blissful getaway alongside Jackson Holliday’s beach workout ❤ Tobias Myers’ quiet departure from Milwaukee is raising eyebrows—and concern. With no clear explanation and few reassurances, what should have been a routine move now feels unsettling, as insiders point to missing details that suggest something more serious beneath the surface. As the team remains silent, speculation is only growing, and the longer answers are withheld, the harder they’ll be to ignore

Baltimore Orioles second baseman Jackson Holliday and his wife, Chloe, are enjoying their tropical vacation in Maui, Hawaii. Chloe has shared a lot of content from their…

REPORT: Spring training just got louder in Baltimore. With a record 20 Spring Training games on MASN and Josh Lewin joining the booth, the Orioles are opening the door wider than ever—giving fans a front-row seat to every pitch, prospect, and rising expectation.

The Orioles announced that they’ll televise a record 20 games from spring training. Nineteen will be called remotely from Baltimore. In previous years, the Orioles and Washington…