11 winners and 4 losers from the Chiefs’ overtime win over the Colts

This past weekend, I was back home for a high school reunion (s/o Plattsburg High School). It felt great to reconnect with old friends and share stories of stuff we almost forgot ever happened. Then — just as gratifying — we all saw the Kansas City Chiefs have a little reunion with themselves, collecting a 23-20 overtime victory over the Indianapolis Colts.

It took a while, but the Chiefs have finally remembered their championship mentality. During Sunday’s matchup, quarterback Patrick Mahomes willed them to a thrilling come-from-behind victory over an AFC contender. They overcame mistakes, made huge plays, got defensive stops and even ran the ball — something we had almost forgotten Kansas City even knew how to do!

Here are a few who stood out as the good guys got reacquainted with the feeling of winning a close game.

 

Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

Quarterback Patrick Mahomes: Welcome back to the quarterback we’ve grown to know and love — the Original Over-My-Dead-Body Man: Patrick Lavon Mahomes II. The announcers realized he was coming back when he started picking up first downs on the ground and firing passes into the chests of receivers: he wasn’t going to allow this one to slip away! Losing close games this season might be a reversion to the mean — but hopefully in Mahomes, we are seeing a reversion to the MVP that will persist into the postseason. Mahomes threw for 352 yards, had a bad interception and was sacked four times. But make no mistake: he made this victory happen.

Running back Kareem Hunt: For what feels like the first time since Larry Johnson was here, the Chiefs ran the ball 40 times. Hunt used that volume to rip off 140 total yards (26 receiving) and a touchdown, looking like the same guy who sparked previous Chiefs victories by refusing to get tackled on first contact. He fought through pain, a fumble, multiple defenders (and a backup offensive lineman) to keep the game close, run the clock and — most importantly — move the chains.

Offensive weapon Brashard Smith: Remember offensive weapons? The Chiefs seemed to always have a little guy who could get to the edge on an end-around — or catch a swing pass and make a big play out of it. It feels like the team forgot how to use a guy like Smith, but it looks like they’ve put the old pages back into the playbook binders. Smith’s 40 yards were key in sparking Sunday’s offense.

Wide receiver Rashee Rice: The Chiefs hadn’t had a 100-yard receiver or running back all season. Rice (along with Hunt) brought the production back. The wideout turned 12 targets into 8 catches for 141 yards. With about 4 minutes left, the Chiefs were backed up near their own goal line and needed a play. Rice answered the call with a terrific 47-yard catch-and-run that gave us hope Kansas City was coming back to win — just like they used to do.

Defenders Bryan Cook, Drue Tranquill, Chamarri Conner, Jaden Hicks and Leo Chenal: Every big game in this dynasty has featured some defensive role players stepping up to get the ball back to Mahomes and the offense. These guys were among those who were flying around in the second half with passes defended, tackles-for-loss and big hits that kept the momentum from swinging back toward Indianapolis. While each has limitations, they each also have a role as an enforcer and complementary playmaker. Kansas City will need all 53 guys to make another run — and Sunday was a reminder that many role players will be part of that winning formula.

Defensive linemen Chris Jones and George Karlaftis: They haven’t peaked yet, but there were signs of life from Sack Nation. Jones and Karlaftis each had two quarterback hits, along with pressure that helped hold Daniel Jones and the top-ranked Colts offense to under 200 yards passing. Jones was also instrumental in getting the crowd fired up — and it was a factor!

 

Running back Clyde Edwards-Helaire: It wasn’t just his lack of production (seven touches for 17 yards), but also the team’s action after the game — signing running back Dameon Pierce — that made it a less-than-ideal day for the running back.

Whoever was supposed to be blocking Germaine Pratt: We typically keep this piece focused on specific members of the Chiefs who made a difference. But on Sunday, Indianapolis fielded an (apparently) unblockable player. Pratt had 20 tackles (two for loss) and a pass defended. He was everywhere, blowing up plays and wrecking drives. Other analysts will figure out who should have been blocking him — and they will have an uncomfortable film room meeting with the coaching staff.

Defensive lineman Mike Pennel: I’m sure the veteran tackle was part of several plays where the Colts’ running game was bottled up. But he also left some opportunities on the field — and was observed making futile efforts to chase down ball carriers. I think we’re all glad he’s back with the Chiefs — but on Sunday, it felt like he was past his prime.

NFL referees: Since we went outside the Chiefs’ circle on Pratt, let’s talk about the officiating. Once again, there were some terrible calls (and missed calls) in this game. As always, there were probably some going both directions. But there were a number of critical calls against Kansas City that could have stopped momentum. Thankfully, the home team overcame them — but the NFL really should do something about the quality of its officiating.

Please note: the labels “winners” and “losers” are not judgments of talent or character. They simply reflect single game performance. No disrespect is intended.

Related Posts

🚨 REPORT PACKERS TARGET “ROB GRONKOWSKI 2.0” MICHAEL TRIGG AT NO. 52 — A BOLD MOVE TO ELEVATE JORDAN LOVE’S OFFENSE, insiders say this potential pick could transform Green Bay’s attack and give Love a new weapon to work with, the stakes are high as the Packers aim to reshape their future with a playmaking tight end 👇👇👇

Green Bay, Wisconsin — The Green Bay Packers may be preparing to make one of the most exciting offensive moves of the 2026 NFL Draft, as momentum…

🚨 BREAKING: After learning he’s being traded to the Steelers, a Ravens defensive star reportedly reacted immediately by threatening retirement and making one thing crystal clear: “I’m not wearing gold.” What should have been a routine move has now turned into an emotional flashpoint, with pride, rivalry, and loyalty suddenly taking center stage. This isn’t just a trade… it’s an internal struggle that could redefine the future of this star.👇👇

OWINGS MILLS, MD — The “Charm City” is iп a state of total disbelief this morпiпg. Followiпg a 2025 seasoп where the Baltimore Raveпs’ defeпse showed flashes…

🚨 BOMBSHELL CHIEFS’ $158 MILLION DEFENSIVE NIGHTMARE SHOCKS NFL BY REJECTING BIGGER OFFERS FROM RAVENS AND 49ERS, CHOOSING LOYALTY TO KANSAS CITY AMID CAP CRUNCH, insiders reveal this stunning decision could define the Chiefs’ defense for years to come, with the team’s salary cap troubles only adding more drama to the already intense situation 👇👇👇

Chiefs’ $158 Million Defensive Nightmare Shocks NFL by Rejecting Bigger Offers From Ravens and 49ers, Chooses Loyalty to Kansas City Amid Cap Crunch Kansas City, MO – As…

🚨 BREAKING: Just 12 hours after NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell suddenly called an emergency meeting with the 32 team owners regarding Governor Jeff Landry’s proposal, Saints owner Gayle Benson surprisingly accelerated the ownership transfer process — the real reason behind that action earns forgiveness from the Saints community! A move that has shocked the entire NFL, as Gayle Benson seemingly did the unthinkable to secure the team’s future. This isn’t just a business decision… it’s a restoration of trust and a commitment to the fans.👇👇

New Orleans, Louisiana – In a stunning development, Gayle Benson moved quickly to accelerate the ownership transfer process just 12 hours after NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell called an emergency meeting with…

🚨 BREAKING NEWS: After A.J. Brown became one of the hottest names on the transfer market, the elite star made a shocking statement — he is willing to turn down massive offers from rival programs just to stay with the Philadelphia Eagles. But what head coach Nick Sirianni said to him next… left the entire A.J. Brown community completely stunned. A response that not only reaffirmed loyalty but also opened up a promising new chapter for both the team and the superstar.👇👇

Rumors had been swirling across the league for weeks as several teams reportedly prepared massive offers to lure the star receiver away from Philadelphia. Executives around the National…

🚨 BREAKING: Ex-Steelers fan favorite linebacker wants back in Pittsburgh with a $3M deal — a surprising move that has fans excited! After time away, he’s eager to return and make an impact for his former team, boosting their defense. This isn’t just an offer… it’s an emotional reunion of a legend in the hearts of Steelers fans. 👏👇

Pittsburgh, PA – The Pittsburgh Steelers could be staring at an emotional reunion opportunity as one of their most respected former defenders signals a strong desire to return…