Should Cubs Make Painful Move And Trade Fan Favorite All-Star While Value Is High?

The Chicago Cubs head into the offseason coming off their first real playoff run in almost a decade, bringing a sense of baseball excitement back to the city and a renewed hope for contention.

President of baseball operations Jed Hoyer knew he had to make big moves in order to get this team back where they belonged — and keep his seat from getting warm — so that is precisely what he did. The Kyle Tucker trade is the first thing that comes to mind when reflecting on last offseason, but Hoyer did a nice job finding value out of his less notable acquisitions as well.

Now, with Tucker likely headed for the exit, Hoyer must figure out his next move to light the world on fire. With a ton of free agents hitting the open market, perhaps Chicago could look to deal from within their own core in order to open up space to shake things up in the lineup.

One particular name makes some sense as someone whom Hoyer could look to dangle as trade bait, both to free up cash as well as a position on the diamond.

Should Cubs Make Painful Move And Trade Fan Favorite All-Star While Value Is High?

Michael McLoone-Imagn Images

Since signing his seven-year, $177 million contract with Chicago prior to the 2023 season, Swanson has quickly become a fan favorite with his elite defense and timely hitting. The numbers with regard to his WAR show his value to the team (13.6 bWAR since 2023), but the offense has not quite been there at the rate the Cubs would have hoped.

Over the last two seasons, the slash line for Swanson has been just .243/.306/.404, and though he has clubbed 40 home runs in that same period after hitting 24 in 2025 for his highest total since joining Chicago, it’s safe to say the bat is not where most expected for a player making nearly $30 million annually.

Swanson makes $28 million for each of the next two seasons before making $27 million in 2028 and $26 million in 2029, at which point he will be 35 years old and likely have seen his defense suffer immensely.

Signing up for four more years while likely knowing his best baseball is already behind him now at 31 is a tough sell. But would Hoyer actually pull the trigger?

Cubs Trading Swanson Now Allows Them to Pursue Younger Talent

Should Cubs Make Painful Move And Trade Fan Favorite All-Star While Value Is High?

Jovanny Hernandez / Milwaukee Journal Sentinel / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Chicago was mentioned this week as a potential free agency fit for Toronto Blue Jays star Bo Bichette, and while the defense would obviously take a hit, Bichette is four years younger than Swanson and among the best pure hitters in all of baseball.

Bichette may wind up switching positions defensively due to his shortcomings with the glove, but it’s safe to say most would take the massive offensive upgrade in exchange for defense that suffers.

MORE: Pope Leo’s Cubs Roast Comes Back To Haunt Him With Latest Jersey Photo Op

Whether it’s Bichette or someone else, though, Swanson will not have higher trade value at any point than right now, so if the Cubs have any reservations about keeping him for almost the entire next half-decade, trading him now should be something they consider.

Don’t hit the ball to Dansby Swanson 😤#Postseason pic.twitter.com/J1RcwFUh0Z

— MLB (@MLB) October 2, 2025

Not only would it likely be a haul in return, but it also opens up an entire world of options for the lineup.

To this point, there’s been no real noise about the possibility of trading Swanson, but it would not be shocking to have it wind up being something Hoyer considers this winter.

The Latest Chicago Cubs News

Why Cubs’ Reported Interest In Top Free Agent Infielder Makes No Sense

Dansby Swanson Reflects On ‘Dang Good’ Cubs Season In Emotional Message

Cubs Need To Run Away From Latest Kyle Tucker Contract Projection — Here’s Why

Cubs Should Be All Over Top Free Agent Ace Pitcher

Related Posts

BREAKING NEWS: Dodgers owe $1.06 billion US in deferred money through 2047 after Edwin Diaz deal

Edwin Diaz won’t receive all of his $69 million from the Dodgers until 2047, with the closer’s deal raising deferred payment obligations for the two-time World Series…

Breaking!! Braves received encouraging news regarding Bo Bichette’s chances after a recent report, sparking optimism among fans and analysts alike. The update could influence roster decisions and the team’s strategy heading into the next stretch of the season. With Bichette’s potential impact under consideration, discussions are heating up about how this could shape Atlanta’s pursuit of postseason success

The Atlanta Braves are having themselves a quality offseason thus far. Atlanta has made two meaningful free-agent signings in Robert Suarez and Mike Yastrzemski. They are also bringing back…

🚨 INSIDE FRONT OFFICE STRATEGY: The White Sox appear to be quietly cornering the market on minor moves, and while these decisions may look small on the surface, insiders believe they reveal a much larger plan taking shape behind the scenes. What Chicago is really building through these low key transactions could surprise fans who are only watching the headlines.

Trying to find players on cheap deals is one thing — but it’s no excuse to continue sidestepping major acquisitions

🚨 INSIDE REALITY CHECK: Hopes of the Braves landing a World Series MVP shortstop are quietly fading, and the reasons behind it go far deeper than price or timing. What’s unfolding behind the scenes suggests Atlanta’s front office may already be closing the door on a move many fans assumed was still very much alive.

The Atlanta Braves have reportedly been interested, but the Rangers are adamant that they won’t make a move

YANKEES STRIKE LATE: New York swoops in on the final signing day to steal a teenage strikeout ace, catching rivals completely flat-footed. Scouts are buzzing, fans are dreaming, and whispers of a future monster arm are spreading fast through the Bronx. One last-day move, one unknown phenom, and the Yankees may have just changed their future overnight..ll

The New York Yankees got in just under the wire of the international signing deadline with an 18-year-old southpaw strikeout pitcher.

🚨 INSIDE BLOCKBUSTER BUZZ: The Phillies are suddenly being projected to pull off a massive All Star trade with the Red Sox, and the ripple effects could reshape both franchises in ways few saw coming. What’s quietly being discussed behind closed doors hints at a bold swing that may change the balance of power sooner than expected.

The Boston Red Sox and Philadelphia Phillies could come together on a big trade that would make sense for both sides.