With the clock ticking down on Willy Adames’ time in Milwaukee, the Brewers’ front office—and fans—are turning their attention to who might fill the void at shortstop. While it’s a tough pill to swallow, the Brewers seem to have already come to terms with the fact that Adames won’t be returning in 2025. So, the burning question isn’t if they’ll bring him back, but who will step up to take his place at one of baseball’s most crucial defensive positions?

Luckily for Milwaukee, they’ve got some promising talent waiting in the wings: Brice Turang and Joey Ortiz. Turang, a homegrown talent and first-round pick from 2018, has quickly made a name for himself with two solid years in the Major Leagues.

He’s coming off a season where he snagged a Gold Glove at second base and even clinched the Platinum Glove as the National League’s top fielder. If you’re looking for a standout candidate to command shortstop, Turang’s resume makes a mighty strong case.

On the other hand, there’s Joey Ortiz, a fresh face in Milwaukee following his move from Baltimore in last year’s Corbin Burnes trade. While Ortiz might not have the Gold Glove hardware just yet, he’s got plenty of swagger in his defensive toolkit—think range, quickness, and a throwing arm that could go toe-to-toe with any shortstop in the game.

Pat Murphy, the Brewers’ esteemed NL Manager of the Year, recently weighed in on the brewing debate during an appearance on Foul Territory. While acknowledging Turang’s clear capability at shortstop, Murphy’s candid insights seem to tip the scales toward Ortiz for the role.

He hinted, “The decision will be one or the other. My tendency is probably to leave Brice alone because he’s as special as you can see at second base.”

Murphy’s philosophy is steeped in the belief that if something isn’t broken, why try to fix it? Turang has proven his prowess at second base—his Gold Glove is a testament to that.

Why risk tampering with success when you have another competent solution like Ortiz ready to step up at shortstop? The move could set the stage for a formidable double-play duo in Milwaukee for years to come.

And let’s talk lineup dynamics. Ortiz hasn’t exactly been the power hitter you’d traditionally want at third base, but his move to shortstop provides an opportunity for the Brewers to bolster their offensive game elsewhere. With Adames’ impressive tally of 32 home runs and 112 RBIs no longer part of the equation, Milwaukee has the chance to seek out a power-hitting corner infielder to fill that gap.

While it remains to be seen who will officially don the shortstop mantle when spring training rolls around, all signs point to Ortiz stepping up. Murphy’s no games, no guessing approach has made it clear: he’s thinking of Ortiz as Milwaukee’s shortstop for the upcoming season. And as Brewer fans gear up for 2025, they do so knowing their infield is in good hands, primed and ready to face what’s ahead.