The Bills’ Safety Dilemma Is Real – and There Are Four Free Agents Who Can Step In Right Now

The Buffalo Bills’ defense has a glaring problem, and it starts deep – literally. With Damar Hamlin landing on injured reserve, the back end of the secondary has become more exposed than ever.

Taylor Rapp and rookie Cole Bishop are plugging holes, but opposing offenses are finding ways to exploit that safety tandem week after week. And if Buffalo wants to stay relevant in the AFC playoff race, they’ll need reinforcements – fast.

Good news for Brandon Beane? There’s no shortage of veteran safeties just waiting for a phone call.

Even better, Beane has never been shy about making in-season additions. So, who should be on the shortlist?

Let’s break down four available names who could step in and immediately give this secondary a much-needed boost.

Jordan Whitehead – Ready to Return and Eager to Prove It

At just 28, Jordan Whitehead still has plenty of football left – and before a car accident in January derailed his offseason with the Buccaneers, he was earning every dollar of a $4.5 million average annual salary. That injury voided his contract, but Whitehead hasn’t stepped away from the game. Now medically cleared and looking for a second shot, he’s available – and hungry.

Whitehead has been the model of consistency over a seven-year career, starting nearly every game he’s suited up for since his rookie season. He’s physical, instinctive, and, importantly for Buffalo, experienced in both single-high and split-safety roles.

In short: Whitehead checks all the boxes for what the Bills need right now. He’s a plug-and-play option who wouldn’t command major dollars and would instantly raise the floor of the safety room, whether or not Hamlin returns this season. If Beane makes a move, Whitehead should be the first call.

Justin Simmons – The Smart, Safe Bet

When you need leadership and coverage IQ in the back end, the list doesn’t get much shorter than Justin Simmons. Four-time second-team All-Pro.

Trusted voice in any locker room. And still extremely capable of playing the deep-third in a zone-heavy scheme.

Yes, Simmons is 31, and no, he’s not exactly at the peak of his powers anymore. But what he brings is poise, intelligence, and range – something that’s been sorely missing in Buffalo’s secondary as of late. He signed a short-term in-season deal with the Falcons last year, so the expectation is he’d do the same again in 2025, likely for something close to the veteran minimum.

It’s not a flashy move. But Simmons can absolutely help stabilize a shaky safety unit while giving the defense someone who won’t get lost in complex coverage checks. For a team seriously thinking about playing deep into January, he’s a steadying force worth bringing in.

Marcus Maye – Physical Depth with Upside

Buffalo fans remember Marcus Maye. From 2017 to 2021, he gave the Bills fits whenever they traveled to New Jersey to take on the Jets. He’s always been known for being a downhill attacker – a strong tackler who doesn’t shy away from contact.

Now, at 28, Maye finds himself looking for a new home after a 2024 season that didn’t quite go as planned. He struggled to earn a role in Miami and ended the year with the Chargers after getting claimed off waivers. It’s not the cleanest résumé recently, but make no mistake – Maye can still play.

He brings physicality and eight seasons of NFL experience to a group that desperately needs someone to match Bishop’s energy with production. Even if he’s not a locked-in starter, Maye can rotate in and bring a presence that’s been missing – especially against the run and in horizontal route coverage.

C.J. Gardner-Johnson – Talented but Unpredictable

On tape, C.J. Gardner-Johnson looks like a dream fit: he’s fast, versatile, and can line up as either a safety or nickel corner.

The kind of chess piece defensive coordinators love. But off-field concerns have cooled his market, and teams have been hesitant to bring him in, with both Houston and Baltimore moving on from him this season.

That said, the Bills are in desperate need of an impact player. Not just a body – someone who can change the dynamic. Gardner-Johnson, still just 26, has proven he can be that kind of player.

Yes, the red flags are there. But in the right culture, with the right leadership – something Buffalo has in spades – CJGJ could find stability. If he can commit to the role and buy in, he might not just fill a need; he could give the defense a jolt of playmaking swagger it sorely lacks.

Bottom Line: Buffalo Needs to Move – Quickly

Fixing the safety group isn’t optional if the Bills expect to make noise down the stretch. Hamlin’s absence has created a major hole, and while Rapp and Bishop are battling, the depth – and top-end talent – just isn’t there right now.

Beane has options. Whitehead brings consistency.

Simmons brings trust. Maye brings pop.

Gardner-Johnson brings upside. And all four are available.

It’s not just about filling a spot. It’s about competing in an AFC that’s getting tighter by the week.

Buffalo doesn’t have time to waste.