Even Chris Sale’s competition thinks Atlanta Braves ace deserves the NL Cy Young

All signs point to Atlanta Braves left-hander Chris Sale winning his first Cy Young award on Wednesday night. The once-borderline hall-of-fame starting pitcher will punch his eventual ticket to Cooperstown after his greatest season as a professional. Sale had a ton of injuries in his early 30s when he was with the Boston Red Sox. It just so happened that his first with the Braves was his best.

While Pittsburgh Pirates rookie Paul Skenes and Philadelphia Phillies right-hander Zack Wheeler would be tremendous candidates most years, neither won the NL Triple Crown like Sale did. Although Detroit Tigers southpaw Tarik Skubal just did the same thing over in the American League, not since Clayton Kershaw did it way back in 2011 has an NL pitcher been this thoroughly dominant in a year.

Skenes will have plenty of time to capture his first, but Wheeler may be looking back at a few starts and wondering what he could have done differently. Regardless, Skenes seems to be well aware that this is Sale’s NL Cy Young award, and his alone. We are talking about a pitcher who put it all together after seasons of great physical struggle to finally put him in the Hall of Fame discussion. He is in now.

Sale led the National League with 18 wins, a 2.38 ERA and 225 strikeouts, nearly identical to Skubal.

Paul Skenes says it’s nice to be considered, but believes that Atlanta veteran Chris Sale will, and should, be the NL Cy Young award winner.

— Bob Nightengale (@BNightengale) November 19, 2024

Atlanta did not have its best season, but where would the Braves have been without Sale’s very best?

For more news and rumors, check out MLB Insider Robert Murray’s work on The Baseball Insiders podcast, subscribe to, our weekly MLB newsletter, The Moonshot and join the discord to get the inside scoop during the MLB offseason.

Let’s be totally honest with ourselves here. This is the right outcome for all three NL Cy Young finalists. For Sale, he gets to join Atlanta starting pitching royalty alongside Tom Glavine, Greg Maddux and John Smoltz. He too will join them in Cooperstown one day. Sale would also be honored with the other Triple Crown winner Skubal. For Skenes and Wheelers, this will serve as motivation.

Skenes is next, but Wheeler is now in the National League. It would not shock me if either of them wins the NL Cy Young next year. In fact, I would say it is infinitely more likely that one of them will win it, as opposed to seeing Sale repeat. Arm trouble in the final weeks of the season contributed to the Braves going out of the playoffs in a dud. Some feel a certain way about it, but that is not the point…

The point is MVP awards and Cy Young awards should honor and recognize greatness in a given season. If they can go to a player on a winning team, then that is wonderful. Baseball can be funny like that sometimes where league MVPs can play for 100-loss teams. The NBA, NFL and NFL would never do such a thing. College football did give Paul Hornung a Heisman Trophy for starring a two-win team.

I just think anytime a pitcher wins the Triple Crown, he should at least get the Cy Young that season.

Next. Top 25 MLB pitching seasons of all time. Top 25 MLB pitching seasons of all time. dark

Related Posts

PHILLIES DRAMA: A Team Legend Steps In After Nick Castellanos’ Controversial Remarks, His “Bad Timing” Message Sparks Tension Inside the Clubhouse, and The Fallout Could Get Messy..ll

Phillies’ Nick Castellanos might have gone too far after Monday’s loss

Yankees Fans Want Aaron Boone Fired ‘Immediately’ Tonight

New York Yankees fans are officially done with Aaron Boone, but is the franchise? The Yankees lost to the Blue Jays, 5-2, in Game 4 of the American League Division Series on Wednesday night. New York, trailing 2-1 heading into Game 4, has officially been eliminated from the postseason. The Yankees …

SCHWARBER ERUPTS: Two Home Runs Power the Phillies Past the Dodgers 8–2, The Statement Win Keeps Their Season Alive, and Momentum Just Swung Back in a Big Way..ll

Schwarber snapped an 0-for-8 skid in the NLDS, slugging a 96-mph fastball from Yoshinobu Yamamoto 455 feet.

Column: Chicago Cubs win a wild one, staving off elimination in Game 3 at a raucous Wrigley Field

In a wild Game 3 that had fans on their feet from beginning to end, the Chicago Cubs beat the Milwaukee Brewers 4-3 to stave off elimination.

HARPER’S WARNING: After Taking Down the Dodgers, Bryce Harper Reveals His Plan for NLDS Game 4, The Confidence Is Off the Charts, and His Next Move Could Flip the Entire Series..ll

Philadelphia Phillies star Bryce Harper shares mindset after Game 3 win as team forces NLDS Game 4 vs. Dodgers to keep the 2025 season alive.

PHILLIES RESURRECTION: The Big Three Come Alive to Stave Off Elimination, Momentum Shifts in Stunning Fashion, and the Series Suddenly Feels Far From Over..ll

LOS ANGELES (AP) – With the Philadelphia Phillies facing elimination, the team’s struggling big three saved the season in a big way, at least for another…