Narrative surrounding Dak Prescott is changing dramatically

Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott has been one of the most divisive quarterbacks in the NFL in recent memory.

On one side, Prescott is seen as overrated and a reason for the Cowboys consistently coming up short when it matters most. On the other hand, he is seen as a player who has made lemonade out of lemons and pulled the Cowboys up to levels they otherwise wouldn’t have been.

Whichever side you fall on, one thing is clear – he is having one of his best seasons ever under center for Dallas, and that continued vs. the New York Jets on Sunday.

MORE: Cowboys’ hidden gem among highest PFF grades against Jets in Week 5

In fact, the national narrative surrounding Prescott has begun to shift as well, with some pundits – most recently FOX Sports’ Colin Cowherd – making the case for Prescott being an MVP candidate despite Dallas being 2-2-1 on the year.

Narrative surrounding Dak Prescott is changing dramatically

Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott stands in the pocket against the New York Jets / Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images

“(Prescott) was a little overrated. Now, Dak, this Dak is not getting enough credit,” Cowherd said. “They don’t have a number one receiver currently, the offensive line is still in a rebuild mode, running game is okay, the staff, fine. Defense last in the league. Dak Prescott, Sam Darnold, Baker Mayfield… It’s like they’ve hit the 10,000-hour rule. They’re all smart guys, but they have reached another level of football IQ, and Dak has gone from a little overrated to now underappreciated. If I had an MVP vote today, I would probably vote Baker Mayfield No. 1 and Dak No. 2.

“I would give Baker it because he’s won more games and he’s won them late. But also, Baker Mayfield has the better General Manager, the better rookie receiver. I think the overall roster in Tampa is much better than the Cowboys’ roster. But this right now, what you’re seeing Dak Prescott do, this is the best Dak you’ve ever seen.”

Its hard to argue against Cowherd either. Especially when you consider the fact that Prescott has been excellent for the last two games without his No. 1 wideout in CeeDee Lamb, and the majority of his starting offensive line.

Not to mention, he also has the Cowboys a couple of Lamb drops vs. the Eagles and a defensive stop vs. the Packers in overtime away from being 4-1.

— Enjoy free coverage of the Cowboys from Dallas Cowboys on SI 

6 winners & 2 losers from Dallas Cowboys blowout win vs Jets Week 5

3 takeaways from Dallas Cowboys’ dominant win over Jets in Week 5

Cowboys’ unheralded duo just did what many team legends never could

Dallas Cowboys mock draft lands team ‘giant & disruptive DT,’ elite cover corner

Cowboys find diamond in the rough after James Houston’s Week 5 performance

PHOTOS: Meet Brenley Herrera, viral Dallas Cowboys Cheerleader rookie

Related Posts

UPDATE: If the Dallas Cowboys bring back Cooper Rush in 2026, it wouldn’t just be a signing — it would be a reunion with a quarterback who knows the system and the spotlight in Dallas. With depth always crucial in a long NFL season, could this familiar face be the steady insurance the Cowboys need?

Could a Reunion Between the Dallas Cowboys and Cooper Rush Happen in 2026? Could the Dallas Cowboys bring back quarterback Cooper Rush in 2026? It’s a question…

BUFFALO BOMBSHELL! Josh Allen Finally Lands His Game-Breaking WR1… But the Jaw-Dropping Cost (First-Round Pick? Star Player? Massive Cap Hit?) Ends Every Excuse for Good – Super Bowl or Bust Now! 😱🦬💥

The Buffalo Bills need a wide receiver. Drafting Keon Coleman in the second round two seasons ago was supposed to help give quarterback Josh Allen a weapon…

Steelers Linked to Elite Wide Receiver in Trade Rumors Resurface

IMAGE: Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Aaron Rodgers (8) drops back to pass against the Baltimore Ravens during the first half at Acrisure Stadium. / Charles LeClaire / Imagn…

STEELERS JUST IGNITED A FIRESTORM CONTROVERSY: HC Mike McCarthy drops the ultimate cryptic bombshell, admitting the team is secretly gearing up for BOTH jaw-dropping scenarios with Aaron Rodgers—will the future Hall of Famer shock the NFL by finally joining Pittsburgh’s reunion dream… or brutally retire and leave Steelers Nation devastated in the darkest timeline?!

New Steelers head coach Mike McCarthy offered some vague, but entertaining updates on veteran quarterback Aaron Rodgers’s NFL future in a radio interview with ESPN Milwaukee on…

SAN FRANCISCO JUST DROPPED A SNEAKY BOMBSHELL: 49ers quietly lock in their former 6th-round hidden gem with a fresh one-year extension—keeping this underrated trench warrior’s untapped potential and battle-tested depth right where Kyle Shanahan needs it most for the 2026 push!

The San Francisco 49ers had a successful 2025 campaign for all intents and purposes, but they still came up short in their quest to win the Super…

49ers just dropped a GAME-CHANGING bombshell: they’ve FINALLY secured their own “Buckner-level” lockdown beast for the secondary in a massive $73.6M trade explosion from the Dolphins—get ready for total domination in the backfield!

In a blockbuster deal that could reshape the NFC West landscape, the San Francisco 49ers have acquired star safety Minkah Fitzpatrick from the Miami Dolphins in a…