Yankees Considering Shocking Benching for Game 1 vs. Red Sox

The New York Yankees will host the Boston Red Sox for an American League Wild Card Series. Garret Crochet and Max Fried are expected to take the mound for Game 1.

With both teams lining their aces up for Game 1, offense may be hard to come by. However, Aaron Boone is making tough decisions in order to maximize the Yankees’ chances of winning. With Fried on the mound, Boone has announced that Austin Wells will catch on Tuesday. He added that Paul Goldschmidt is likely to start at first base against Crochet.

Wells and Goldschmidt starting would mean Ben Rice will start the game on the bench. Rice has the third-highest OPS on the team, but has not played well against left-handed pitching. He has just a .208 average and a .752 OPS against southpaws. Boone noted that he has not made a final decision about who will play first base, but made it clear that Goldschmidt will “probably” be there on Tuesday.

Yankees Considering Shocking Benching for Game 1 vs. Red Sox

Crochet is one of the best pitchers in the sport and has made four starts this season against the Yankees. He has a 3.29 ERA in 27 1/3 innings. He also has 39 strikeouts. Crochet has dominated against left-handed hitters this season, playing into the team’s decision to likely start Goldschmidt at first base.

Goldschmidt has hit .336 with a .981 OPS against southpaws this season. He also has a pair of hits and a walk against Crochet this season. The real question for the Yankees was whether to start Wells or Rice behind the dish.

Rice has been much better offensively this season, and both have struggled against southpaws. Neither has great numbers against Crochet either. However, the decision likely came down to Fried’s comfort level at catcher.

Wells has caught Fried 27 times this season, as opposed to just once for Rice. Sending Rice out to catch Fried for just the second time could prevent Fried from dominating, which is not a risk the Yankees likely want to take. Rice has been a great player for the Yankees’ offense, but the Yankees will essentially be forced to keep him on the bench to start the game.

Leaving Rice’s bat out of the lineup is a tough blow. However, Goldschmidt has dominated lefties and deserves to draw the start at first base. The Yankees will need Wells to step up offensively since the Yankees are having to bench Rice to start him at catcher.

More MLB: Giants Fire Manager Bob Melvin After Missing Playoffs

Related Posts

🚨 BREAKING: Mets sign OF Melendez to a one‑year contract — New York adds speed and pop to the outfield mix in a savvy offseason move! With Melendez locked in, expectations are rising that he could provide a spark atop the lineup and bolster depth across the diamond. Is this the missing piece the Mets needed to make noise in 2026? The MLB world is paying attention..ll 👇👇👇

NEW YORK METS SIGN MJ MELENDEZ TO ONE-YEAR CONTRACT: A MOVE TO ADD DEPTH TO THE OUTFIELD 🚨 MET’S NEW ACQUISITION TO STRENGTHEN OUTFIELD DEPTH: The New…

🚨 EXCLUSIVE: Bo Bichette is the top projected NY Mets newcomer, but the second name on the list may surprise every fan — Mets insiders are buzzing as projections place an unexpected star right behind Bichette! With New York gearing up for a massive offseason shakeup, these two additions could redefine the roster’s trajectory. The MLB landscape might not be ready for what’s coming next..ll 👇👇👇

MARCUS SEMIEN PROJECTED TO OUTPERFORM FREDDY PERALTA IN 2026 WAR PROJECTIONS FOR NEW YORK METS 🚨 A SURPRISING PROJECTION FOR THE NEW METS: As the New York…

🚨 EXCLUSIVE: Dodgerѕ’ Dаve Robertѕ thrіlled to hаve Kіké Hernаndez, Evаn Phіllірѕ bаck – LA’ѕ mаnаger іѕ over the moon аѕ two key рlаyerѕ return, reаdy to mаke аn іmmedіаte іmраct on the рlаyoff рuѕh! The excіtement іѕ раlраble аѕ Hernаndez аnd Phіllірѕ brіng energy аnd exрerіence bаck to the ѕquаd. Could thіѕ dynаmіc duo be the mіѕѕіng ріece for а deeр рoѕtѕeаѕon run? The MLB world іѕ buzzіng..ll 👇👇👇

LOS ANGELES DODGERS MAKE MOVES WITH KEY RE-SIGNINGS AND NEW ADDITIONS 🚨 DODGERS CONTINUE OFFSEASON STRATEGY WITH VETERAN MOVES: The Los Angeles Dodgers are not slowing down…

🚨 BREAKING: Dodgers’ Max Muncy, Enrique Hernandez agree to deals – the powerhouse duo is locked in, sending shockwaves through the league as LA continues to build its championship contender! Fans are fired up as the pair’s return strengthens the roster and puts the Dodgers in prime position for another title run. Can this be the move that secures their future? The MLB world is watching..ll 👇👇👇

LOS ANGELES DODGERS MAKE MOVES WITH MAX MUNCY EXTENSION, ENRIQUE HERNANDEZ RETURN, AND OTHER TRANSACTIONS 🚨 DODGERS EXTEND MUNCY, RE-SIGN HERNANDEZ, AND CONTINUE OFFSEASON ACTIVITY: The Los…

🚨 BOMBSHELL: Mariners’ whiff on Roki Sasaki looks like a blessing amid Dodgers drama – what seemed like a missed opportunity is now looking like a stroke of luck as the Japanese phenom’s situation turns chaotic! With the Dodgers in turmoil, Seattle’s decision may have just saved them from a major disaster. Could this unexpected twist be the break the Mariners needed? The MLB world is in disbelief..ll 👇👇👇

SEATTLE MARINERS ESCAPE THE HEADACHE OF PURSUING ROKI SASAKI: A “WHAT COULD HAVE BEEN” STORY 🚨 A TURN OF FORTUNE FOR THE MARINERS: As Seattle Mariners fans…

🚨 BOMBSHELL: Yankees receive concerning injury update on breakout postseason pitcher – the rising star’s health is now in serious jeopardy, and the team’s playoff hopes could be on the line! With the latest setback, New York faces a critical crossroads as they wait for more news. Could this be the blow that derails their championship run? The MLB world is on edge..ll 👇👇👇

NEW YORK YANKEES FACE SETBACK WITH CAM SCHLITTLER’S BACK INJURY, BUT HOPE REMAINS FOR 2026 🚨 A BUMP IN THE ROAD FOR THE YANKEES’ PITCHING STAFF: As…